DVD Verdict
Home About Deals Gift Guide Blu-ray DVD Reviews Upcoming DVD Releases Contest Podcasts Judges Jury Room Contact  

Judge Dossier

Judge Adam Arseneau

Judge Adam Arseneau • Joined: May 2003
• Retired: May 2012
• 450 full reviews
• 135 small claims

• Read Judge Arseneau's Blog

 

Rulings

.45
The A&E Adventure Collection
ABC News Presents: The Search For Jesus
Able Edwards
Adopt A Sailor
Adventures of Louanna Lee: I'm Here to Tell You
After.Life (Blu-Ray)
Age Of Stupid
The Agronomist
Air America (Blu-Ray)
Airline: The Complete Season One
Aliens: Collector's Edition
The Alien Quadrilogy
Almost Heaven
Altitude (Blu-Ray)
American Gun
American Outrage
Ancient Mysteries: UFOs ... The First Encounters
And Soon The Darkness (Blu-Ray)
Angel Guts: The Nikkatsu Series
Angel Wars: The Messengers
Animaniacs: Volume 1
Apartment Zero
Appleseed (Blu-Ray)
Appleseed: Ex Machina
Appleseed (UMD Mini for PSP)
Argento Soma: Another Reality (Volume 1)
Argento Soma: Getting Even (Volume 2)
The Art Of Pain
Audition (Blu-Ray)
Avatar: The Last Airbender: The Complete Book 1 (Collector's Edition)
Babylon A.D. (Blu-Ray)
Bad Meat (2003)
Bakugan, Volume 1: Battle Brawlers
Bakugan, Volume 2: Game On
Bakugan, Volume 3: Good Versus Evil
Balzac And The Little Chinese Seamstress
The Bandit Of Sherwood Forest
The Bedford Incident
Behind The Mask: The Rise Of Leslie Vernon
Bellflower (Blu-ray)
The Best Of Arli$$
The Best Of The Colbert Report
A Better Tomorrow I + II
The Big O II: Paradigm Lost (Volume 1)
The Black Society Trilogy: Shinjuku Triad Society
The Black Society Trilogy: Rainy Dog
The Black Society Trilogy: Ley Lines
Black Society Trilogy: Special Limited Edition
Bleach: Volume 5
Blind Spot: Hitler's Secretary
Blown Away
Blue Bloods: The First Season
Blue Murder: Complete Collection
Bomb The System
Botched
Bottle Shock
Bottom Of The Sea
Boy A
Bra Boys
Brainstorm
Breach
Breaking News
The Brief: Complete Collection
Bright Future
Broken (2005)
The Broken
Broken Saints: The Animated Comic Epic
Brotherhood: The Complete First Season
Buckethead: Secret Recipe
Budo: The Art Of Killing
Bullet Ballet
Bunny Chow
Bury My Heart At Wounded Knee
The Butcher Boy
Cambridge Spies
Cannibal
Capturing The Friedmans
Caroline In The City: The First Season
Casino Jack And The United States Of Money
Casshern
Castle In The Sky: Two-Disc Special Edition
Cheers: The Complete Second Season
Cheers: The Complete Third Season
Cheers: The Complete Fourth Season
Cheers: The Complete Fifth Season
Childstar
Choi Lee Fut
Chowder: Volume 2
Christianity The First Two Thousand Years
Circle Of Iron
City Of God
City Of Men
City Of Men: The Complete Series
Claymore: The Complete Series
Close To Home
Close Your Eyes
Collapse
Comedy Central Roast Of Flavor Flav
Confetti
Count Basie: Live In Berlin And Stockholm 1968
Count Basie: Swingin' The Blues
Countdown To Zero (Blu-Ray)
Cronicas
Crossing Jordan: Season One
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon / Curse Of The Golden Flower / House Of Flying Daggers (Blu-Ray)
The Crusades: Crescent & The Cross (Blu-ray)
Cul de Sac: A Suburban War Story
The Cure: Trilogy (Blu-Ray)
The Daily Show With Jon Stewart: Indecision 2004
Danny Roane: First Time Director
Dave's World: The First Season
David Copperfield: Illusion
Day Night Day Night
Dead & Buried (Blu-Ray)
Dead Cool
Dead Heat On A Merry-Go-Round
Dead Like Me: Life After Death
Dead Man's Shoes
Death Note: Volume 1
Death Note II: The Last Name
Death Note: Re-Light, Volume 1
Defying Gravity: The Complete First Season
Devil Hunter Yohko: The Complete Collection
Dexter: The First Season
Dexter: The Second Season (Blu-ray)
Director's Label Series Boxed Set: The Works Of Spike Jonze, Chris Cunningham, And Michel Gondry
Discovery Atlas: Complete Collection (Blu-Ray)
Dj Spooky's Rebirth Of A Nation
D.N. Angel: Complete Collection
Doctor Strange: The Sorcerer Supreme
Doctor Who: The Complete Fifth Series (Blu-Ray)
Dominion: Prequel To The Exorcist
Done The Impossible: The Fans' Tale Of Firefly And Serenity
Dorf Goes Fishing / Tim And Harvey In The Great Outdoors
Do The Right Thing (Blu-Ray)
Dragon Age: Redemption
Dragon Ball Z: Dragon Box One
Dragon Ball Z: Dragon Box Three
Dragon Ball Z: Dragon Box Two
Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog (Blu-Ray)
Driftwood
Dying God
Edge of Darkness (1985): The Complete Series
8 Mile (Blu-Ray)
11:14
Elvis: 75th Birthday Collection
EM Embalming
Emerson, Lake And Palmer: Live At Montreaux 1997 (Blu-Ray)
Empires: Holy Warriors: Richard The Lionheart And Saladin
The End Of America
Epitafios: The Complete First Season
ER: The Complete Sixth Season
ER: The Complete Ninth Season
ER: The Complete Tenth Season
ER: The Complete Fourteenth Season
Escape To Canada
Evan Almighty
Evangelion 1.11: You Are (Not) Alone
Everything's Gone Green
Fallen Angel
Family (2001)
Far Cry
Farmingville
Fear(s) of the Dark
Femi Kuti: Live At The Shrine: Deluxe Edition DVD + Live CD
Fidel Castro
The Final Cut
Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children: Two-Disc Special Edition
Fist Of The North Star (Volume 5)
The Fourth Kind
Fraggle Rock: The Complete First Season
Franklyn (Blu-Ray)
Fratricide
Freestyle: The Art Of Rhyme
The Fresh Prince Of Bel-Air: The Complete Third Season
Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Part One
Fushigi Yugi: The Mysterious Play...The Return Home (Volume 2)
Fushigi Yugi: The Mysterious Play...Trials Of A Priestess (Volume 3)
Futurama: Bender's Game
Gangland: The Final Season (Blu-Ray)
The Gang That Couldn't Shoot Straight
Gantz: The Complete Series
Garfield: Cat Tales Gift Set
Gargoyles: The Complete First Season
Garuda
Gasland
Gate Of Flesh: Criterion Collection
Gavin & Stacey: The Complete Collection
G.B.H.
General Hospital: Night Shift: Complete First Season
Genesis: The Video Show
Ghost Hunters: Military Investigations
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex: 2nd Gig (Volume 1)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex: 2nd Gig (Volume 2)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex: 2nd Gig (Volume 3)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex: 2nd Gig (Volume 4)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex: 2nd Gig (Volume 5)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex: 2nd Gig (Volume 6)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex: 2nd Gig (Volume 7)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex: 2nd Gig: Individual Eleven
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex: The Laughing Man
Ghosts Of Cite Soleil
Ghostwriter: Season One
The Girl Next Door (Blu-Ray)
Glastonbury
The Grateful Dead Movie (Blu-ray)
The Great Kat: Beethoven's Guitar Shred
The Great Yokai War
Green Day: Bullet In A Bible
Green Zone (Blu-Ray)
Greg The Bunny: The Complete Series
The Guard From Underground
A Guide To Recognizing Your Saints
The Guild: Season Three
Gunner Palace
Gym Teacher
Handy Manny: Big Race
Happiness
Harsh Times (Blu-Ray)
Heater
Heavy Metal In Baghdad
The Henry Rollins Show: Season One
Henry Rollins: Uncut from NYC
Hercules: The Legendary Journeys, Season Five
Hey, Happy!
A History Lesson, Part 1: Punk Rock In Los Angeles In 1984
Hollow Man: Director's Cut
Honey And Clover
Hoop Days: Zone 1
Hostel: Part II
House Of The Rising Punk
How I Met Your Mother: Season Five
How The Earth Was Made
How The Earth Was Made: The Complete Season One (Blu-Ray)
Hustle: Complete Season One
Hype
Ichi
Ichi The Killer: Blood Pack
If God Is Willing And Da Creek Don't Rise
If You Were Young: Rage
Ikki Tousen: The Complete Series
I Knew It Was You: Rediscovering John Cazale
I'll Sleep When I'm Dead
Indie Sex
Infamy
Inked: Best Of Season One
In Living Color: Season Five
In The Realm Of The Senses: Criterion Collection (Blu-Ray)
In Treatment: Season Two
The Invisible
Ip Man (Blu-Ray) Collector's Edition
Iraq For Sale: The War Profiteers
Jane Goodall's Return To Gombe
The Jeff Corwin Experience
Jews And Baseball: An American Love Story
JFK: A Presidency Revealed
The Job: The Complete Series
Johnny Clegg With Savuka And Juluka: Live! And More...
John Scofield: New Morning, The Paris Concert
Jo Koy: Don't Make Him Angry!
Junior (2002)
Just Peck
Kagemusha: Criterion Collection
Kanto Wanderer
Kaze No Stigma: Volume 1
Kenny Vs. Spenny: Volume One
Kichiku Dai Enkai
Kickboxer 3 / Kickboxer 4
A Killing In A Small Town
Kill Your Idols
Know Your Mushrooms
Kwoon
Labyrinth: Collector's Edition
La Chinoise
La Haine: Criterion Collection
The Last Chapter
The Last Days Of World War II
The Last Round: Chuvalo Vs. Ali
The Last Winter
Law And Order: The Fourth Year
Law And Order: The Fourteenth Year
Law And Order: Special Victims Unit: The Eighth Year
Law And Order: Special Victims Unit: The Eleventh Year
Law And Order: Special Victims Unit: The Seventh Year
Law And Order: Special Victims Unit: The Sixth Year
Law And Order: Special Victims Unit: The Third Year
Le Chevalier D'Eon: Volume 1
Le Chevalier D'Eon: Volume 2
Le Chevalier D'Eon: Volume 3
Left Of The Dial
Legally Blondes
The Legend Of The Mystical Ninja: The Fight For Justice (Volume 2)
Leon: The Professional: Superbit Edition
Les Miserables In Concert: 25th Anniversary (Blu-ray)
Lethal Chiba
A.LI.CE
License To Wed
Life After People
Live From Tokyo
Look! Playful Patterns And Simple Shapes / Go! Exercise With The Teletubbies
Lost: The Complete First Season
The Lost Treasure Of The Grand Canyon
Love Ghost
Love Hina Again
Lovely By Surprise
L/R (Licensed By Royalty): Broken Angel (Volume 3)
Lunar Legend Tsukihime: Life Threads (Volume 1)
Macbeth (2006)
Maiko Haaaan!!!
Mamoru Oshii's Stray Dog
Mamoru Oshii's Talking Head
Mamoru Oshii's The Red Spectacles
Mandrake: Seasons 1 and 2
Man Stroke Woman: The Complete Series
Marebito
Marillion: Live From Cadogan Hall
The Marshall Tucker Band: Live From The Garden State 1981
Mary-Kate And Ashley: The Challenge
Masters Of Horror: Takashi Miike: Imprint
Master Spy: The Robert Hanssen Story
The Matrix Reloaded
Meat Weed America
Memories
Memories Of Murder
Men With Guns
Mesrine: Killer Instinct, Part 1
Metal: A Headbanger's Journey
The Method (El Metodo)
MI-5: Volume 2
Midnight Crossing
Midnight Express (Blu-Ray)
The Midnight Meat Train
The Mighty Boosh: The Complete Season 1
Mike Hammer, Private Eye: The Complete Series
Mongol
Monster Garage: Season One
The Motel
Mr. Bill's Disasterpiece Theater
Mrs. Miracle
MTV's Pimp My Ride: The Complete First Season
Mummies: Secrets Of The Pharaohs (Blu-Ray)
Murder Investigation Team: Series One
Murder Princess: The Complete Series
Murphy's Law: Series Three
Murphy's Law: Series Two
Mushi-Shi: The Movie
Music Box
Music For Montserrat
MXP: Most Xtreme Primate
Mysteries Of The Freemasons
The Naked Brothers Band: Polar Bears
Nana
Naruto: Volume 15
Naruto The Movie: Shippuden
Naruto The Movie: Ninja Clash In The Land Of Snow
Neil Gaiman's Neverwhere
Never Been Thawed
New Tricks: Season One
New Tricks: Season Two
New World Order
Next Day Air
Niacin: Live In Tokyo
Night Catches Us (Blu-Ray)
Nightmare Detective
Nobody
Noein: Volume 1
Noein: Volume 2
Noein: Volume 3
Noein: Volume 4
Nora Roberts' Tribute
Not Easily Broken (Blu-Ray)
A Not So Silent Night At The Knitting Factory
The Omega Factor: The Complete Series
On The Outs
Our Family Wedding
Outsourced (2006)
Overnight
The Oxford Murders
Artists Of The 20th Century: Pablo Picasso
Pale Flower
Paranormal State: Season One
Paranormal State: Season Two
Perpetual Peace
Pickpocket
Ping Pong
Ping Pong Playa
Pinky And The Brain: Volume 1
Pinky And The Brain: Volume 2
Pipes Of Peace
Pixar Short Films Collection: Volume 1
Platinum Comedy Series: Bruce Bruce
Please Teacher: Meet The In-Laws (Volume 2)
Please Teacher: The Honeymoon's Over (Volume 3)
Please Teacher: Hello Again (Volume 4)
Primeval: Volume Two
Primeval: Volume One
Prince Of Thieves
Princess
Project Blue Earth SOS: The Complete Series
Proof (2004)
Pu-239
Public Enemy: Revolverlution Tour 2003 Manchester
Pulse (Kairo)
Puzzle
Queen Sized
Radiant City
Ramsay's Kitchen Nightmares: Complete Series One
Ran (Blu-Ray)
Reconstruction
Red Dawn (1984)
Red Dust
The Red Green Show: 2001 Season
Rescue Me: The Complete Second Season
Returner
Revealing The Leopard
The Riches: Season 1
Ripley's Believe It Or Not
The Rise And Fall Of ECW
Roger & Me
Rogues Of Sherwood Forest
Ronin (Blu-Ray)
Ronin Warriors OAV (Volume 2)
The Ron White Show
The Running Man: Special Edition
Russell Brand In New York City
The Sacred Triangle: Bowie, Iggy And Lou (1971-1973)
The Saddest Music In The World
Sailor Moon: Super S: The Complete Uncut TV Series
The Sailor Who Fell From Grace With The Sea
Sakura Diaries: Secrets And Lies (Volume 1)
Sakura Diaries: Love And Kisses (Volume 2)
Sakura Wars TV: Complete Collection
The Salamander
Samurai Champloo: Episodes 1 and 2 (UMD Mini For PSP)
The Samurai Collection Featuring Sonny Chiba
Sanctuary: The Complete Second Season
Saturday Night Live: The Best Of Adam Sandler
Saturday Night Live: The Best Of Chris Farley
Saturday Night Live: The Best Of Christopher Walken
Schoolgirl Report 1: What Parents Don't Think Is Possible
Scrubs: The Complete Third Season
Scum
Scummy Man
The Sea Inside
The Second Best Science Fiction Movie Ever Made
Second Sight: Complete Collection
Secrecy
The Secret World Of Alex Mack: Season One
Sex And The City: The Complete Fourth Season
Shadow Warriors: The Complete First Season
Sheitan
The Sherlock Holmes Collection
Shockheaded
The Shogun Collection
The Show
Single-Handed: Set 1
16 Wishes
Sixteen Years Of Alcohol
The Skulls: Night Of The Living Skulls
The Sky Crawlers (Blu-Ray)
Slings & Arrows: The Complete Collection (Blu-Ray)
A Snake Of June
Sondheim: The Birthday Concert (Blu-Ray)
Sonny Chiba Collection
Sordid Lives: Complete Series
Soul Hunter: The Complete Collection
Soul Of The Sword
Soundstage Presents: Umphrey's McGee... Live
Spartacus: Blood And Sand: The Complete First Season
Special
Speed Dating
Spice And Wolf: Season One
Spike And Mike's Sick And Twisted Festival Of Animation: Contagious
Spirited Killer Trilogy
Spirit Of Wonder
Squat 69
Stargate: The Ark Of Truth
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, Season Three
Star Trek Fan Collective: Captain's Log
The Star Wars Trilogy
State Of Play (2003)
St. Elsewhere: Season One
Still Waiting... (Blu-ray)
Stoked: The Rise And Fall Of Gator
Stop Making Sense (Blu-Ray)
Story Of A Prostitute: Criterion Collection
Strangers With Candy: The Complete Series
Street Fighter Alpha: Generations
Stuck
Stupidity
Suicide Club
SuicideGirls: The First Tour
The Suite Life Of Zack And Cody: Lip Synchin' In The Rain
The Suite Life Of Zack And Cody: Sweet Suite Victory
Supercop: Two-Disc Ultimate Edition
Sweet Violence
SXSW Live 2007
Taggart: Killer Set
The Take (2004)
Tapped
Ted Nugent: Motor City Mayhem (Blu-Ray)
Teenage Paparazzo
Tell Them Anything You Want: A Portrait Of Maurice Sendak
10 Items or Less: Seasons 1 & 2
These Amazing Shadows: The Movies That Make America
Third Watch: The Complete First Season
This Is England
3000 Miles
The Tibetan Book Of The Dead
The Tiger Next Door
Time Bandits (UMD Mini For PSP)
Time Warp: Season One (Blu-Ray)
Titus: Seasons One And Two
Titus: Season Three
Todd McFarlane's Spawn: The Animated Collection
Tokyo Sonata
Tokyo Zombie
Tom Petty And The Heartbreakers: Damn The Torpedoes (Blu-Ray)
Top Chef: New York
Toto: 25th Anniversary (Live In Amsterdam)
Traitor
Transformers: Season Three, Part Two And Season Four
Beast Wars: Transformers: The Complete Second Season
Triad Election
Tricheurs
Trigun: The $60,000,000,000 Man
Trigun: The Complete Series
The Trotsky
Tupac: Resurrection
29 Palms
Two Evil Eyes (Blu-Ray)
2009: Lost Memories
Typhoon
UFOs Do Not Exist!
Ugly Betty: The Complete First Season
The Ultimate Gift
The Universe: The Complete Season Four (Blu-Ray)
Unmistaken Child
Unscripted
Vans Warped Tour 2007
Van Wilder: Freshman Year (Unrated)
Vida Blue With The Spam Allstars: Live At The Fillmore
Viva La Bam: Complete Seasons Two And Three
The Wackness
Waltz With Bashir
Warm Water Under A Red Bridge
Warren Miller's Journey
Warren Miller's Journey Through The Decades
Warriors (Guerreros)
Warriors Of Heaven And Earth
The Warriors: Ultimate Director's Cut
Wayside School: Season One
Wedding Daze
Weeds: Season Four
Weekend (1967)
Welcome to the NHK: Volume 1
Welcome To The NHK: Volume 2
Welcome to the NHK: The Complete Series
The West Wing: The Complete Fifth Season
What Girls Learn
When The Levees Broke: A Requiem In Four Acts
When You're Strange: A Film about The Doors (Blu-ray)
White Collar: The Complete First Season
The Who: Live At The Isle Of Wight 1970
Wild Life
Wild Pacific
Winged Migration
The Wire: The Complete Third Season
The Wire: The Complete Fourth Season
The Wire: The Complete Fifth Season
Witch Hunter Robin: Arrival
Within (2008)
Without A Trace: The Complete Second Season
Wizards
The Wooden Camera
The Work Of Director Chris Cunningham
The Work Of Director Spike Jonze
World Poker Tour: Season Two
The Wrong Arm Of The Law
Wrong Turn 3: Left For Dead
Wyclef Jean: All Star Jam At Carnegie Hall
Xena: Warrior Princess, Season Six
xxxHOLIC: The Complete Series
The Yes Men
You Kill Me
Youth Of The Beast: Criterion Collection
Yozakura Quartet: Complete Collection
Z Rock: Season 1
Z Rock: Season 2

DVD Verdict Quick Index

• Blu-ray Release Dates 2012
• DVD Release Dates 2012
• DVD Reviews 2012
• Search for a DVD review...


Average Scales of Justice

Video: 84
Audio: 85
Extras: 34
Acting: 80
Story: 78
Judgment: 79

Scale Modifiers

Video: +2
Audio: +1
Extras: +25
Acting: +4
Story: +1
Judgment: 0

The Scale Modifiers are the difference between the Judge's average scores and the average scores for the site as a whole. You can add/subtract this value from the score he/she gives in a review to see how their scoring differs from the site as a whole. The adjusted score should not reflect any bias on the part of the judge.






DVD | Blu-ray | Upcoming DVD Releases | About | Staff | Jobs | Contact | Subscribe | Find us on Google+ | Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2014 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.