DVD Verdict
Home About Deals Gift Guide Blu-ray DVD Reviews Upcoming DVD Releases Contest Podcasts Judges Jury Room Contact  

Judge Dossier

Judge Ryan Keefer

Judge Ryan Keefer • Joined: June 2005
• Retired: January 2009
• 336 full reviews
• 130 small claims

• Read Judge Keefer's Blog

 

Rulings

AC/DC: No Bull (Blu-ray)
The Adventures Of Robin Hood (HD DVD)
Albert Collins: Live At Montreux 1992
Alexander Revisited: The Final Cut (Blu-Ray)
Alex Kovalev: My Training Methods
Alison Krauss: A Hundred Miles Or More, Live From The Tracking Room
All The President's Men: Two-Disc Special Edition
American Gangster (HD DVD)
American Hardcore
Apocalypto (Blu-Ray)
Are We Done Yet? (Blu-Ray)
The Arizona Diamondbacks 2001 World Series Collector's Edition
Arlington Road (Blu-Ray)
The Art Of Soccer With John Cleese
August Rush (Blu-Ray)
The Aviator (Blu-Ray)
Bad Santa: The Unrated Version And Director's Cut (Blu-Ray)
The Ballad Of Cable Hogue
Baltimore Orioles Legends: Cal Ripken Jr. Collector's Edition
Bandidas
Baseball's Greatest Legends: Diamond Memories
Batman: Special Edition
Batman Begins (HD DVD)
Battle Of Britain (Blu-Ray)
Battle Of The Bulge (HD DVD)
Beerfest (HD DVD)
Ben-Hur: Four-Disc Collector's Edition
Bewitched
The Big Lebowski (HD DVD)
Black Book (Blu-Ray)
Black Snake Moan (HD DVD)
Blades Of Glory (Blu-Ray)
Blood Diamond (Blu-Ray)
Borat: Cultural Learnings Of America For Make Benefit Glorious Nation Of Kazakhstan
Born On The Fourth Of July (HD DVD)
Boston Celtics 1985-86 NBA Champions
Boston Celtics: 2007-2008 NBA Champions
Boston Red Sox 2004 World Series: Collector's Edition
The Boston Red Sox: Essential Games Of Fenway Park
Bram Stoker's Dracula (Blu-Ray)
Bratz: Fashion Pixiez
A Bridge Too Far (Blu-Ray)
Bridge To Terabithia (Blu-Ray)
Broken Trail
Bruce Almighty (HD DVD)
The Bucket List (Blu-Ray)
Bugsy: Extended Cut
Bullitt (HD DVD)
Butch Cassidy And The Sundance Kid: Two-Disc Collector's Edition
Caddyshack (HD DVD)
Camp Rock (Blu-Ray)
Capote
Carlito's Way: Ultimate Edition
Carlos Santana Presents: Blues At Montreux 2004
Cars (Blu-ray)
Casino (Blu-Ray)
Casino Royale (2006)
Cast Away (Blu-Ray)
Catch A Fire (1999)
Catch And Release (Blu-Ray)
Charlie And The Chocolate Factory (HD DVD)
Charmed: The Complete Second Season
Charmed: The Complete Third Season
Charmed: The Complete Eighth Season
The Chicago White Sox: 2005 World Series
The Chris Rock Show: The Complete First And Second Seasons
A Christmas Story (Blu-Ray)
The Chronicles Of Narnia: The Lion, The Witch And The Wardrobe (Four-Disc Extended Edition)
Chuck: The Complete First Season (Blu-Ray)
Chuck Berry Hail! Hail! Rock 'n' Roll: Ultimate Collector's Edition
The Cincinnati Reds 1975 World Series: Collector's Edition
Cinderella Man
CJ7 (Blu-Ray)
A Clockwork Orange (Blu-ray)
Close Encounters Of The Third Kind (Blu-ray)
The Company (Blu-Ray)
Corpse Bride (HD DVD)
Cowboy Del Amor
The Cowboys (HD DVD)
Cream: Classic Artists
Curse Of The Golden Flower (Blu-Ray)
Daddy Day Camp (Blu-Ray)
Dallas Cowboys: 10 Greatest Games
Damages: The Complete First Season (Blu-Ray)
Dan In Real Life (Blu-Ray)
Daredevil (Blu-ray)
Dare To Dream: The Story Of The U.S. Women's Soccer Team
Darkman (HD DVD)
David Beckham: Life Of An Icon
David Spade: Take The Hit
Dawn Of The Dead (Blu-Ray)
Dawson's Creek: The Complete Fifth Season
Day Of The Dead (Blu-Ray)
Daytona 500: 50 Years Of The Great American Race
Day Watch (Blu-Ray)
Death Proof (Blu-Ray)
Deck The Halls
The Deer Hunter (HD DVD)
Deja Vu (Blu-Ray)
Deliverance (Blu-Ray)
Dennis Miller: All In
The Departed (HD DVD)
The Dick Cavett Show: Ray Charles Collection
Digital Video Essentials HD (HD DVD + DVD Combo Disc)
The Dirty Dozen (HD DVD)
Dodger Blue: The Championship Years
Dog Day Afternoon (HD DVD)
Dog the Bounty Hunter: The Best Of Season Two
Dog the Bounty Hunter: The Arrest
Dog the Bounty Hunter: The Best Of Season Three
Dog the Bounty Hunter: The Wedding Special
Don't Come Knocking
The Doors: 15-Year Anniversary Edition
Dreamgirls: Two-Disc Showstopper Edition (HD DVD)
The Dukes Of Hazzard: Unrated (HD DVD)
Dumbo: Big Top Edition
The Eagles: Farewell 1 Tour: Live From Melbourne
Elvin Jones: Jazz Machine
Elvis Presley: The Ed Sullivan Shows
Enchanted (Blu-Ray)
Engelbert Humperdinck: Totally Amazing
ER: The Complete Fifth Season
Eric Clapton: Live At Montreux 1986
Everybody Hates Chris: The First Season
Everybody Loves Raymond: The Complete Sixth Season
Everybody Loves Raymond: The Complete Seventh Season
Everybody Loves Raymond: The Complete Eighth Season
Evil Dead II (Blu-ray)
Excalibur (HD DVD)
Experience Hendrix
Eyes Wide Shut: Special Edition (Blu-Ray)
Failure To Launch (Blu-Ray)
The Family Stone
Fantastic Four: Rise Of The Silver Surfer (Blu-Ray)
A Father... A Son... Once Upon A Time In Hollywood
Ferris Bueller's Day Off: Bueller... Bueller... Edition
Fever Pitch (2005)
A Few Good Men (Blu-Ray)
The FIFA 2006 World Cup Film: The Grand Finale
FIFA Fever
Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within (Blu-Ray)
Finding Neverland (Blu-Ray)
A Fish Called Wanda: Collector's Edition
Flags Of Our Fathers: Two-Disc Special Edition (HD DVD)
Flatliners (Blu-Ray)
The Fly (Blu-Ray)
The Fountain (Combo HD DVD And Standard DVD)
Frasier: The Complete Sixth Season
Frasier: The Complete Eighth Season
Frasier: The Complete Ninth Season
Friends: The One With All The Weddings
From Hell (Blu-Ray)
The Fugitive (HD DVD)
Full Metal Jacket (HD DVD)
Gangsta Rap: The Glockumentary
Garden State
Gene Simmons Family Jewels: The Complete Season 1
George Carlin: Doin' It Again
The Getaway (1972) (Blu-Ray)
Ghost Whisperer: The Second Season
Gilmore Girls: The Complete Fourth Season
Ginger Baker: In Africa
The Girls Next Door: Season Three
Gods And Generals (Blu-Ray)
Golf Magazine Top 100 Teachers: The More Series
Goodfellas (HD DVD)
The Good Shepherd (HD DVD)
Gossip Girl: The Complete First Season
Grand Prix (HD DVD)
Greatest Games In Stanley Cup History: Game 7 Collection
Gridiron Gators: History Of Florida Gator Football
Grizzly Man
Gus Van Sant's Last Days
Hairspray (2007) (Blu-ray)
Halloween (Blu-Ray)
Happy Feet: (Combo HD DVD And Standard DVD)
Harry And Tonto
Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix (Blu-Ray)
High And Low: Criterion Collection
The High And The Mighty
High School Musical 2: Extended Edition (Blu-Ray)
The Hills Have Eyes 2 (Blu-Ray)
Hill Street Blues: The Complete Second Season
The History Of Notre Dame Football
History Of Texas Longhorns Football
History of the MLS Cup
The Holiday (Blu-Ray)
Hollow Man: Director's Cut (Blu-Ray)
Home of the Brave (2006) (Blu-ray)
Homicide: Life On The Street: The Complete Seventh Season
Hondo
Honor And Courage: Tough Guys Of The NHL
Hostel (Blu-ray) Director's Cut
Houston Dynamo: MLS 2007 Cup
How I Met Your Mother: Season Two
The Hurricane (HD DVD)
Hustle And Flow (HD DVD)
Identity (2003) (Blu-ray)
I Know Who Killed Me (Blu-Ray)
I Love Lucy: The Complete Sixth Season
Blue Planet (IMAX) (Blu-ray)
Immortal Beloved (Blu-Ray)
Inside The Actors Studio: Dave Chappelle
In The Valley Of Elah (HD DVD)
The Invisible (Blu-Ray)
Island In The Sky
Jackass 2.5
Jackass Number Two: Unrated Edition
Jackass: The Box Set
Jackie Brown: Collector's Edition
Jailhouse Rock (Blu-Ray)
James Brown: Live At Montreux 1981
James Last: Live At The Royal Albert Hall
The Jerk (HD DVD)
The Jewel Of The Nile: Special Edition
Jimi Plays Monterey / Shake! Otis At Monterey: Criterion Collection
Judas Priest: Live Vengeance '82
Kingdom Of Heaven: Four-Disc Director's Cut
King Kong (1933)
Kiss Kiss, Bang Bang (Combo HD DVD And Standard DVD)
Lancelot Link: Secret Chimp
Land Of The Blind
The Leaders: Breaking The Racial Barriers In The NFL
Legends In Pinstripes (Babe Ruth: The Life Behind The Legend / Where Have You Gone Joe Dimaggio / The Definitive Story Of Mickey Mantle)
Legends: Live At Montreux 1997 (Blu-Ray)
Lethal Weapon 2 (HD DVD)
License To Wed (Blu-Ray)
Little Miss Sunshine
The Lives Of Others (Blu-Ray)
The Longest Day
Long Way Round
The Lookout (Blu-ray)
Lord Of War
The Lords Of Discipline
Los Angeles Dodgers 1988 World Series: Collector's Edition
Los Angeles Lakers 1985 NBA Champions: Return To Glory
Lost: The Complete Fourth Season (Blu-Ray)
Lost In Translation (HD DVD)
Made Of Honor (Blu-Ray)
Mallrats: 10th Anniversary Extended Edition
Mamma Mia! The Movie (Blu-Ray)
Man In The Moon / Benny And Joon
Manning, Brady, Favre: The Quarterbacks
Man On Fire (Blu-Ray)
Mark Messier: Leader, Champion, And Legend
The Marlon Brando Collection
Married Life (Blu-Ray)
M*A*S*H: Season Eleven
Masters Of Horror: Season 1, Volume 1 (Blu-Ray)
Masters Of Horror: Season 1, Volume 2 (Blu-Ray)
Masters Of Horror: Season 1, Volume 3 (Blu-Ray)
Masters Of Horror: Season 1, Volume 4 (Blu-Ray)
McLintock!
The Mel Brooks Collection
Memoirs Of A Geisha (Blu-Ray)
The Messengers (Blu-Ray)
Mi Amigo
Miami Vice: Season Two
Michael Clayton (Blu-Ray)
Midnight Run (HD DVD)
Million Dollar Baby (HD DVD)
Millions
Miss Congeniality 2: Armed And Fabulous
Mission: Impossible: III (HD DVD)
Mission: Impossible (Blu-Ray)
Mission: Impossible II (Blu-Ray)
Monk: Season Three
Monty Python's Flying Circus: Graham Chapman's Personal Best
Monty Python's Flying Circus: Terry Gilliam's Personal Best
Monty Python's Flying Circus: Terry Jones' Personal Best
Monty Python's The Meaning Of Life (HD DVD)
The Moody Blues: Lovely To See You Live (Blu-Ray)
Mr. And Mrs. Smith (Blu-Ray)
Mr. And Mrs. Smith: Unrated Two-Disc Collector's Edition
Mrs. Harris
Mr. Woodcock (Blu-Ray)
Muhammad Ali: Made In Miami
Napoleon Dynamite: Like, The Best Special Edition Ever!
NASCAR: Full Throttle Adrenaline
Natural Born Killers (Blu-Ray)
The Natural: Director's Cut
Naturally 7: Live At Montreux 2007
Nature Boy Ric Flair: The Definitive Collection
NBA Houston Rockets 1994 Champions: Clutch City
NBA Indiana Pacers Greatest Games Collection, Volume 1
NBA: Lights Out
NBA Street Series: Volume 4: Class Of '03
The New Adventures Of Old Christine: The Complete First Season
The New Adventures Of Old Christine: The Complete Second Season
Newlyweds: Nick And Jessica: The Final Season
NewsRadio: The Complete First And Second Seasons
New York Mets: 1986 World Series
The New York Mets: Essential Games Of Shea Stadium
New York Yankees 1977 World Series Collector's Edition
The New York Yankees: Essential Games Of Yankees Stadium
The New York Yankees Fall Classic Collector's Edition 1996-2001
Next (Blu-Ray)
NFL: Brett Favre Forever
NFL Film Classics: Legends Of Autumn, Vols. 1-3
NFL Films: Denver Broncos: The Complete History
NFL Films: San Francisco 49ers: The Complete History
NFL: Greatest Super Bowl Moments (2005)
NFL: Greatest Super Bowl Moments (2006)
NFL: In Just One Play
The NFL's Funniest Players
NFL Super Bowl XLI: Indianapolis Colts Championship DVD
NHL: Philadelphia Flyers 10 Greatest Games Set
Nickelback: Live At Sturgis 2006
Nina Simone: Live At Montreux 1976
1900: Special Collector's Edition
No Country For Old Men (Blu-Ray)
Norbit (HD DVD)
Not Just The Best Of The Larry Sanders Show
Ocean's Thirteen (Blu-Ray)
Ocean's Trilogy (Blu-Ray)
Oldboy (Blu-Ray)
Old School (Blu-Ray)
The Old Settler
The Other Boleyn Girl (Blu-Ray)
The Outsiders: The Complete Novel
Over There: The Complete Series
Ozzy Osbourne's Ozzfest 10th Anniversary
Pan's Labyrinth: Two-Disc Platinum Series
Paprika (Blu-Ray)
Pat Garrett And Billy The Kid: Special Edition
Pathfinder (Blu-Ray)
The Patriot (Blu-Ray)
Paul Mooney: Know Your History - Jesus Was Black, So Is Cleopatra
Payback: Straight Up (HD DVD)
The Perfect Storm (HD DVD)
Perfect Stranger (Blu-Ray)
The Philadelphia Phillies: 2008 World Series Collector's Edition
Pittsburgh Pirates: The 1979 World Series
Pittsburgh Steelers: 5 Greatest Games
Platoon: 20th Anniversary Collector's Edition
The Polar Express: Special Edition
Premonition (Blu-Ray)
Primeval (Blu-Ray)
Prison Break: Season One (Blu-ray)
The Proposition (2005)
P.S. I Love You (Blu-Ray)
The Queen (Blu-Ray)
Raging Bull: Collector's Edition
Ravi Shankar: The Concert For World Peace
The Reaping (Blu-Ray)
Reign Over Me (Blu-Ray)
Remember The Titans (Blu-Ray)
The Replacement Killers (Blu-Ray)
Rescue Dawn (Blu-Ray)
Reservoir Dogs: 15th Anniversary Edition
Resident Evil (Blu-Ray)
Resident Evil: Extinction (Blu-Ray)
Revolver (2007) (Blu-Ray)
Richard Pryor: Live In Concert
Ride The High Country
Ring Of Fire: The Emile Griffith Story
Rio Bravo (Blu-Ray)
Rob And Big: The Complete Third Season
Rob And Big: The Complete Seasons 1 And 2
The Rock: The Most Electrifying Man In Sports Entertainment
Rocky: Two-Disc Collector's Edition
Roll Bounce
Romancing The Stone: Special Edition
The Rookie (Blu-Ray)
Roving Mars (Blu-Ray)
Rumor Has It... (Combo HD DVD And Standard DVD)
Ryan's Daughter
Saints And Soldiers
The Santa Clause 3: The Escape Clause (Blu-Ray)
Santana: Hymns For Peace, Live At Montreux 2004 (HD DVD)
Saturday Night Live: The Best Of John Belushi
Saturday Night Live: The First Five Years
Save The Tiger
Scarecrow (1973)
Scent Of A Woman (HD DVD)
Scrubs: The Complete Fifth Season
Scrubs: The Complete Seventh Season
The Searchers (HD DVD)
Seven Men From Now
Seven Years In Tibet (Blu-Ray)
Shakira: Oral Fixation Tour (Blu-Ray)
Shaquille O'Neal: Like No Other
The Shawshank Redemption (Blu-Ray)
The Simpsons: The Complete Sixth Season
The Simpsons: The Complete Ninth Season
Sisterhood Of The Traveling Pants
Smallville: The Complete Sixth Season (HD DVD)
Smokey And The Bandit (HD DVD)
SNL in the '80s: Lost and Found
The Sopranos: Season Six, Part II
The Sopranos: Season Six, Part I
South Park: The Complete Eighth Season
South Park: The Complete Ninth Season
South Park: The Complete Tenth Season
South Park: The Complete Eleventh Season
Space Cowboys (HD DVD)
Spider-Man 3 (Blu-Ray)
Squidbillies: Volume 1
Standard Operating Procedure (Blu-Ray)
Star Wars Episode III: Revenge Of The Sith
Steep (Blu-Ray)
Sting Jamaica 2003
The Sting: Legacy Series Edition
The St. Louis Cardinals 2006 World Series Collectors Edition
The Strat Pack: Live In Concert (Blu-Ray)
Sunshine (Blu-Ray)
Superbad (Blu-Ray)
Super Bowl XXXI-XL Collector's Set
Super Freak Live 1982
Superman II: The Richard Donner Cut (HD DVD)
Superman: The Movie (HD DVD)
Supernatural: The Complete Third Season (Blu-Ray)
Surf's Up (Blu-Ray)
Syriana (HD DVD)
Talk To Me (HD DVD)
Taxi: The Complete Third Season
Ted Nugent: Sweden Rocks
Tekkonkinkreet (Blu-Ray)
The Ten Commandments: 50th Anniversary Collection
Tennessee Titans: 3 Greatest Games
300 (Blu-Ray)
Titanic (1997) Collector's Edition
TMNT (Blu-ray)
Tommy Boy: Holy Schnike Edition
The Tomorrow Show: John, Paul, Tom And Ringo
The Tomorrow Show: Punk And New Wave
Toy Story: 10th Anniversary Edition
Trading Places: Special Collector's Edition (Blu-Ray)
Training Day (HD DVD)
Troy: Director's Cut (Blu-Ray)
Troy (HD DVD)
True Grit (1969) Special Collector's Edition
Twisted Sister: Live At The Astoria
Two And A Half Men: The Complete Third Season
Two And A Half Men: The Complete Fourth Season
2001: A Space Odyssey: Special Edition (Blu-Ray)
U2: The Joshua Tree
UFC: Ultimate Comebacks (Blu-Ray)
The Ultimate Matrix Collection (Blu-Ray)
Underworld (Blu-Ray)
Unforgiven (HD DVD)
The Untold Story Of Emmett Louis Till
The Untouchables (HD DVD)
The Upside Of Anger
Vacancy (Blu-Ray)
V For Vendetta (HD DVD)
Viva Baseball
Viva Las Vegas (Blu-Ray)
The War (HD DVD)
War Of The Worlds (2005)
Warren Miller: Playground (Blu-Ray)
We Are Marshall (Blu-Ray)
We Own The Night (Blu-Ray)
What Happens In Vegas (Blu-Ray)
The Who At Kilburn 1977 (Blu-Ray)
The Wicker Man (2006) (HD DVD)
The Wild Bunch (Blu-Ray)
The Wild Bunch: The Original Director's Cut
Wild Hogs (Blu-Ray)
Wild Things: Unrated Edition (Blu-ray)
Willy Wonka And The Chocolate Factory (HD DVD)
The Wizard Of Oz: Special Edition
World Poker Tour: The Best Of Season Three
World Series 2005: Chicago White Sox
Wyatt Earp (Blu-Ray)
X-Men: The Last Stand
Yankee Stadium: Baseball's Cathedral
Yellow Sky
Ziggy Marley: Love Is My Religion

DVD Verdict Quick Index

• Blu-ray Release Dates 2012
• DVD Release Dates 2012
• DVD Reviews 2012
• Search for a DVD review...


Average Scales of Justice

Video: 87
Audio: 86
Extras: 49
Acting: 83
Story: 80
Judgment: 81

Scale Modifiers

Video: -1
Audio: 0
Extras: +10
Acting: +1
Story: -1
Judgment: -2

The Scale Modifiers are the difference between the Judge's average scores and the average scores for the site as a whole. You can add/subtract this value from the score he/she gives in a review to see how their scoring differs from the site as a whole. The adjusted score should not reflect any bias on the part of the judge.






DVD | Blu-ray | Upcoming DVD Releases | About | Staff | Jobs | Contact | Subscribe | Find us on Google+ | Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2014 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.