Total DVD Reviews: 13,632
Egos crushed: 12
DVD Verdict
Home DVD Reviews Upcoming DVD Releases Cinema Verdict TV Verdict Podcast Contest Forums Judges Contact Us Subscribe  

Blog From The Bench

Judge Joe Armenio's Blog

Judge Joe Armenio • Location: Cleveland, OH
• Member since: March 2005
• 54 full reviews
• 12 small claims

• Read Judge Armenio's full dossier
• E-mail Judge Armenio

 

The Ice Harvest (Ramis, 2005)

December 1st, 2005 8:20PM

A whole lot of nothing-- tired heist-gone-wrong shenanigans, glib violence, a dose of anti-middle-class-respectability, with Christmas, a la Bad Santa, as the emblem of all things domestic, and just a hint of the earlier film's reluctant but central sentimentalizaing of the (surrogate) father-child relationship. Oliver Platt's comic drunk gives fullest voice to the movie's ideology, and the only interesting scene is his desecration of Christmas dinner, presided over by his silent ice-queen wife, representing domesticity, alluring but inscrutable and conniving and castrating; on the other hand Cusack's scattershot attempts to attain manhood and impress the equally conniving femme fatale by becoming an outlaw and killer are, in the noir tradition, doomed from the start. Not new ideas by any means, still potentially interesting in their troubled and troubling macho way; the whole thing is so slight and tossed-off, though, that it all feels empty rather than ambiguous or unsettling.

Trackback

The trackback URL for this entry is:
http://www.dvdverdict.com/judgeblog/trackback/570

Note that trackbacks are held for moderation prior to posting.