Case Number 10349


Paramount // 1960 // 1037 Minutes // Not Rated
Reviewed by Judge Cynthia Boris (Retired) // November 17th, 2006

The Charge

"Hey Pa, there goes another grown-up lady in trousers!"
-- Opie to his father upon their arrival in Hollywood.

Opening Statement

When I reviewed the fourth season of The Andy Griffith Show, I began by saying this:

Mayberry. Over the years, it has become a symbol of America. A place where apple pies are always cooling on the windowsill. Where a date means skipping stones across Old Man Johnson's lake and the purchase of a new car is wildly celebrated by everyone in town. And though I've never lived in a place like this, I'm told that Mayberry (in the symbolic sense) exists or did exist at one time. I wouldn't know. I live in Orange County, California, where none of the above applies. Sometimes I wish it did; maybe that's why I really enjoyed watching The Andy Griffith Show: The Complete Third Season.

Since then, I've been told that there still are places in America that are just like Mayberry. I gave that idea a lot of thought and came up with this -- nice place to visit but I wouldn't want to live there. I'm glad I live in Southern California, and how appropriate is it that in The Andy Griffith Show: The Complete Sixth Season, Andy and the family visit Southern California and their thought is just the same -- nice place to visit but they wouldn't want to live there.

Facts of the Case

It's our sixth visit to this charming '60s sitcom about a widower sheriff named Andy (Andy Griffith), his son, Opie (Ronny Howard, Happy Days) and a community of slightly eccentric characters who all live in the small, small town of Mayberry, North Carolina.

This season includes:

Disc One:
* "Oppie's Job"
* "Andy's Rival"
* "Malcolm At the Crossroads"
* "Aunt Bee, The Swinger"
* "The Bazaar"
* "A Warning From Warren"

Disc Two:
* "Off to Hollywood"
* "The Taylors in Hollywood"
* "The Hollywood Party"
* "Aunt Bee on TV"
* "The Cannon"
* "A Man's Best Friend"

Disc Three:
* "Aunt Bee Takes a Job"
* "The Church Organ"
* "Girl Shy"
* "Otis, The Artist"
* "The Return of Barney Fife"
* "The Legend of Barney Fife"

Disc Four:
* "Lost and Found"
* "Wyatt Earp Rides Again"
* "Aunt Bee Learns to Drive"
* "Look, Paw, I'm Dancing"
* "The Gypsies"
* "Eat Your Heart Out"

Disc Five:
* "A Baby in the House"
* "The County Clerk"
* "The foster Lady"
* "Goober's Replacement"
* "The Battle of Mayberry"
* "A Singer in Town"

The Evidence

The start of the sixth season came with many changes for the Andy Griffith family. The most obvious change was the disappearance of Don Knotts as Barney Fife. The word is, Knotts was only contracted for five seasons. Never thinking the show would go more than that, he contracted to make movies with Universal Studios and thus wasn't available when the show was picked up. Barney does make an appearance about halfway through the season for a short story arc, but the loss of his character does change the whole dynamic of the series.

In the impossible position of replacing Knotts, was Jack Burns of Burns and Schreiber. Burns brought his trademark, "yeah, huh, yeah, huh, yeah, huh-huh-huh" shtick to the character of Warren Ferguson, Andy's new deputy. Personally, I like Burns. He was a popular comic actor of the era and his distinctive voice can be heard in dozens of cartoons including The Simpsons,, and Wait Till Your Father Gets Home and he's the voice of one of the famed Crash Test Dummies. Sadly, many fans of the series weren't willing to give him a fair shake and he was quickly written out of the show. With Barney and Warren gone, the lesser characters of Floyd, Goober and later Howard Sprague (played by Jack Dodson) were given more screen time but no one had the chemistry with Griffith that Knotts did.

What people may not realize about season six is that it also heralded the exit of producer Aaron Ruben and along with him the majority of the writing staff. It's felt that the new writing staff, regardless of how talented they were, weren't able to capture the same homey, small town feel that was the series' trademark. Instead of being the laid back voice of reason in the middle of tornado, Andy becomes tense, whiney and he yells a lot. Several episodes have him in the dog house with girlfriend Helen and frankly, he seems like he's just had enough of the whole crowd around him.

Another oddity of this season is a change in locale. This set contains a four-episode story arc where Andy, Opie and Aunt Bee go to Hollywood to see the movie that's being made about Andy's life. Gavin McLeod makes a very funny appearance as the actor playing Andy in the movie but, other than that, these episodes just don't work for me. Andy is so uncomfortable playing the fish out of water that I'm uncomfortable watching him, and that's not a good thing.

As for the DVD itself, Paramount gets kudos for detail on the packaging. Each snap case has a themed graphic with the list of episodes (Opie's report card, a sheriff's incident report, a Hollywood scrapbook). Open the cases to find more detailed themed graphics and episode titles and descriptions, which is very handy. The color scheme is very intriguing and the art has a painted quality to it. Beyond the packaging there's nothing special here. No extras, nothing but a mono soundtrack and clean but underwhelming video quality.

Closing Statement

Though I haven't seen the episode "A Singer in Town" in more than 10 years, I can still remember the song that Aunt Bee and Clara wrote and honestly, it still brings a tear to my eye. It's the perfect final episode for the season because it reminds us of what the show is all about.

My home town is the greatest place I know,
Where the neighbors I find are gentle and kind,
And the living is easy and slow,
My hometown is the only place to be,
Here the worries are small, and the kids grow tall and healthy and free,
It's my hometown, my hometown, Mayberry, Mayberry.

The Verdict

Sorry, but we can't render a verdict because the circuit judge is up in Mount Pilot officiating over the centennial quilting bee and jam making contest. Understand? Yeah. Huh? Yeah. Huh? Yeah. Huh-huh-huh.

Review content copyright © 2006 Cynthia Boris; Site layout and review format copyright © 1998 - 2016 HipClick Designs LLC

Scales of Justice
Video: 90
Audio: 90
Extras: 0
Acting: 85
Story: 80
Judgment: 69

Perp Profile
Studio: Paramount
Video Formats:
* Full Frame

Audio Formats:
* Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono (English)

* None

Running Time: 1037 Minutes
Release Year: 1960
MPAA Rating: Not Rated

Distinguishing Marks
* None

* IMDb

* The Andy Griffith Rerun Watchers Club