Case Number 10171


Warner Bros. // 1932 // 412 Minutes // Rated G
Reviewed by Judge Brett Cullum // October 16th, 2006

The Charge

6 Masterworks of Terror!

Opening Statement

In the '30s studios were going horror crazy with good reason. Universal had been saved by its monster films, including Dracula and Frankenstein, because terror pictures always -- surprisingly -- made more money than they cost to produce. Audiences loved spooky tales of the supernatural, and film was the perfect medium to deliver them. Whenever Hollywood gets a hold of a profitable idea, they milk it for all it's worth, and the collection in my hands now proves that fact. Hollywood Legends of Horror Collection assembles six features made on the Warner Brothers and MGM lots as the studios tried to replicate Universal's success with vampires, ghouls, and mad scientists. The films are all camp classics of the genre, but nowhere near as iconic as the Universal "monster mashes." Many of these films haven't been seen in their original versions since they were in nickel movie houses back in the day. So how does Warner Brothers treat the Legends of Horror Collection?

Facts of the Case

The Mask of Fu Manchu (1932)
Boris Karloff (Frankenstein) appears as the infamous Chinese villain, and does an admirable job under Oriental make-up. Fu Manchu is searching for the tomb of Ghengis Khan and an artifact or two that will give him powers to rule the world. This DVD presentation is notable for reinserting a couple of minutes of deleted material including a racist rant from Karloff.

Doctor X (1932)
A bumbling newspaper man (LeeTracy) follows the trail of a serial killer to a mansion filled with scientists trying to capture a killer. The large cast features Lionel Atwill and a pre-King Kong Fay Wray in this comedy horror flick shown in partial color with a two-strip Technicolor process. This DVD marks the first time viewers can see the color print instead of the black-and-white version which was filmed simultaneously.

Mark of the Vampire (1935)
A series of murders are believed to be the work of the undead. Director Todd Browning remakes his own London After Midnight, casting Bela Lugosi (Dracula) as head vampire Count Mora. Lionel Atwill gets to reinvent the heroic inspector Newman. Lon Chaney had played both roles previously in the Browning-directed original.

Mad Love (1935)
Colin Clive plays a piano virtuoso named Stephen who loses his hands in a gruesome train accident. His wife arranges for him to be treated by one of her admirers, the spooky Dr. Gogol (Peter Lorre). The lovestruck doctor gives the pianist an evil knife thrower's hands, and soon the mitts start trouble of their own.

The Devil Doll (1936)
Lionel Barrymore is a Parisian banker named Paul who is framed for robbery and murder, and sent to Devil's Island. In prison he meets a mad scientist who has perfected miniaturization and decides to use the doctor's devilish techniques to turn the tables on the men who got him incarcerated. It's one of the great Todd Browning freak shows!

The Return of Doctor X (1939)
Humphrey Bogart is cast as a vampiric lab assistant who needs blood to survive. Yes, that Bogart is playing the role because he whined to studio head Jack Warner he was typecast. The film has never been seen on VHS or DVD, so it's a rare treat to see Bogart slum it in a horror picture that has nothing to do with the first movie.

The Evidence

All of the featured movies represent the creaky good-natured horror that was a trademark of the era. Sets are shadowy, characters are all played over the top, and camp rules the night as supernatural happenings slam through the everyday world. Classic horror fans will be in heaven as the DVDs unspool a double feature of fright on each disc. Big-name actors such as Bela Lugosi, Boris Karloff, Peter Lorre, Fay Wray, Humphrey Bogart, Lionel Atwill, Myrna Loy, Maureen O'Sullivan, and Lionel Barrymore seem to be having as much fun as the audience vamping it up in their respective roles (okay, Bogart wasn't too happy about it, but he's still a hoot in The Return of Doctor X).

Transfers vary in quality throughout the set with the later films looking much better than the earlier ones. Notable among the presentations are the two-strip Technicolor print of Doctor X as well as the uncut delivery of The Mask of Fu Manchu. Both of these 1932 features look worn, but we've never seen them in these incarnations. You won't mind the grain and scratches, because they lend a quirky charm particular to these old-time flicks. Doctor X's limited color palette is a unique experience, and the process works well for a horror tale. The later pictures look clear as a bell in many cases (The Return of Doctor X looks brand-new), and receive near-pristine transfers. Audio wavers now and then like the picture, but for the most part captures all the orchestral melodrama and insanely loud female screams well in the original mono mixes. The Mask of Fu Manchu's reinserted sequences look worse than the proper feature, but the footage helps flesh out the main character.

Five of the six movies receive full-length commentaries, with only The Devil Doll missing a track to further explore it (hear me grumble, since it's one of my favorites). The participants are academics who reveal historical anecdotes as well as appropriately salacious gossip about the directors, actors, and productions. The commentaries are as much fun as the features, proving film scholars love these projects as much as we do. It's a great package of extras for some old-time shockers. The packaging includes a nice cardboard case housing three slim-line cases with the original posters displayed for each title.

The Rebuttal Witnesses

Hollywood Legends of Horror doesn't feature any truly unforgettable classics, or any film on par with the Universal monster series or Val Lewton's psychological revolutions for RKO. The six films are admittedly "also rans," projects made to make money and offer audiences a good time more than anything else. Even when they were made, the pictures were "B"-level popcorn sellers the studios tossed off without much care about quality or artisanship. They all feel light and airy for horror films, even from the '30s. While Lugosi, Lorre, and Karloff were committed to the genre, most of the other actors seem merely to be passing time slumming in scary movies.

Closing Statement

The secret behind this set is that it's not a group of classic movies, but a stretch of old-fashioned fun that can't be denied. Mad scientists, vampires, Fu Manchu, zombie bunnies, and fast-talking reporters hot on the trails of them all -- these are the familiar elements celebrated in Hollywood Legends of Horror Collection. This sextet of cinema is nowhere near as significant as the Val Lewton box set or the Universal Legacy releases, but it provides as many sly smiles and good-natured eye rolls as one could expect. Hollywood Legends of Horror Collection is a '30s horror collectors dream of significant actors taking on quirky roles in creepy camp. It's the perfect Halloween collection release, a treat for film buffs who yearn for black-and-white fright in great abundance. Wonderful packaging and a healthy dose of extras add to all the fun.

The Verdict

Hollywood Legends of Horror Collection is an undeniable treat with a few tricks up its sleeves. Not guilty of anything more than a sly wink and a spooky smile, it's the most fun you'll have this year with a horror collection.

Review content copyright © 2006 Brett Cullum; Site layout and review format copyright © 1998 - 2016 HipClick Designs LLC

Scales of Justice
Video: 90
Audio: 85
Extras: 92
Acting: 85
Story: 80
Judgment: 90

Special Commendations
* Golden Gavel 2006 Nominee

Perp Profile
Studio: Warner Bros.
Video Formats:
* Full Frame

Audio Formats:
* Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono (English)

* English
* French
* Spanish

Running Time: 412 Minutes
Release Year: 1932
MPAA Rating: Rated G

Distinguishing Marks
* Commentary for Mark of the Vampire by Film Historians Kim Newman and Steve Jones
* Commentary for The Mask of Fu Manchu by Author Greg Mank
* Commentary for Doctor X by Horror Scholar Scott MacQueen
* Commentary for The Return of Doctor X by Director Vincent Sherman and Author Steve Haberman
* Commentary for Mad Love by Author Steve Haberman

* IMDb: The Devil Doll

* IMDb: Mad Love

* IMDb: Mark of the Vampire

* IMDb: Doctor X

* IMDb: The Mask of Fu Manchu

* IMDb: The Return of Doctor X