DVD Verdict
Home About Deals Gift Guide Blu-ray DVD Reviews Upcoming DVD Releases Contest Podcasts Judges Jury Room Contact  

Case Number 18753: Small Claims Court

Buy The Abbott And Costello Show: The Complete Series at Amazon

The Abbott And Costello Show: The Complete Series

E1 Entertainment // 1952 // 1680 Minutes // Not Rated
Reviewed by Judge Kent Dixon (Retired) // April 21st, 2010

• View Judge Dixon's Dossier
• E-mail Judge Dixon
• Printer Friendly Review


Every purchase you make through these Amazon links supports DVD Verdict's reviewing efforts. Thank you!




 

All Rise...

Judge Kent Dixon is a baaaaaaaaaaaaaaad boy!

The Charge

Heyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy Abboooooooooooott!

The Case

It's impossible to think of comedy without thinking of Bud Abbott and Lou Costello. Few other names are as synonymous with slapstick, improv, and situational comedy than this duo who first worked together in 1936. Bud and Lou gave us the straight man and bumbling sidekick delivery that formed the core of their work in burlesque shows, serial radio, feature films, and The Abbott and Costello Show which ran for two seasons from 1952-53.

All 52 episodes of The Abbott and Costello Show are included with this release, spread across eight discs, allotting the first four discs to Season One and the remaining four to Season Two:

Disc One
•  "The Drug Store"
•  "The Dentist's Office"
•  "Jail"
•  "The Vacation"
•  "The Birthday Party"
•  "Alaska"
•  "The Vacuum Cleaner Salesman"

Disc Two
•  "The Army Story"
•  "Pots and Pans"
•  "The Charity Bazaar"
•  "The Western Story"
•  "The Haunted House"
•  "Peace and Quiet"
•  "Hungry"

Disc Three
•  "The Music Lovers"
•  "The Politician"
•  "The Wrestling Story"
•  "Getting a Job"
•  "The Chimp"
•  "Hillary's Birthday"
•  "Television"

Disc Four
•  "Las Vegas"
•  "Little Old Lady"
•  "The Actor's Home"
•  "Police Rookies"
•  "Safari"

Disc Five
•  "The Paper Hangers"
•  "Uncle Bozzo's Visit"
•  "In Society"
•  "Life Insurance"
•  "Pest Exterminators"
•  "Killer's Wife"
•  "Cheapskates"

Disc Six
•  "South of Dixie"
•  "From Bad to Worse"
•  "$1,000 TV Prize"
•  "Amnesia"
•  "Efficiency Experts"
•  "Car Trouble"
•  "Wife Wanted"

Disc Seven
•  "Uncle From New Jersey"
•  "Private Eye"
•  "The Tax Return"
•  "Public Enemies"
•  "Bank Holdup"
•  "Well Oiled"
•  "The Pigeon"

Disc Eight
•  "Honeymoon House"
•  "Fencing Master"
•  "Beauty Contest Story"
•  "Fall Guy"
•  "Barber Lou"

Aside from the odd episode I caught here and there over the years, this was the first opportunity I've had to sit down and watch the entire run of The Abbott and Costello Show. While the formula stays the same from episode to episode, each show featured a different storyline that allowed Abbott and Costello to shine with their signature mix of misunderstandings, physical comedy, and rapid-fire exchanges. What really made the series work was not only the skills of its headliners, but also the talented supporting cast, each solid comedians in their own right: Sidney Fields (Jackie Gleason and His American Scene Magazine), Gordon Jones (The Shaggy Dog), Joe Besser (Africa Screams), and Hillary Brooke (The Man Who Knew Too Much). While Seinfeld's supporting cast only played one character throughout their series' run, you can easily see how Abbott and Costello's formula and cast inspired Jerry and his creative team as they developed their own "show about nothing."

Bud and Lou's first known radio appearance was "The Kate Smith Hour" in March 1938, where they debuted their now-legendary "Who's On First" routine. Both hailing from New Jersey, Abbott and Costello's voices were a bit too similar and hard to distinguish on radio, so Costello adopted the higher pitched and more childlike voice he is known for today. The duo developed their signature style of the bumbling Lou and the hard-nosed Bud during their time on radio and it wasn't long before they'd honed their act to near perfection. As their popularity increased and their fan base grew, Universal recognized the team's potential and signed them to a long-term deal that resulted in 36 films between 1940 and 1956. Somehow, amidst their busy film schedule, they also managed to create a television series recognized by many as one of the 100 greatest shows of all time; a well-deserved accolade indeed.

Even though they got their start in the often risqué world of burlesque, Abbott and Costello's style of comedy was always clean, never resorting to crude or vulgar material for laughs, unlike many of today's comedians. Their family-friendly content never seemed to hurt their careers, even boosting their fame due to a broader range of appropriateness and appeal.

Restored and remastered, the black & white episodic content fares remarkably well, considering the source material is now nearly 60 years old. There are remarkably few blemishes or damage visible and while a bit on the hot side at times, the whites are clean with a decent amount of contrast between a wide range of greys and blacks. I was expecting the video presentation to be soft or distorted, but was surprised to find the picture quality above average throughout. While somewhat limited by the nature of the original sound elements, the 2.0 mono audio mix does the job, remaining mainly clear, aside from the odd pop or crackle.

As extra features go, the tip of the iceberg begins with the self-explanatory "Classic Routine Reel" from Disc Four of Season One, and two short offerings of "Lou Costello Home Movies: At Home" and "Lou Costello Home Movies: In Europe" on Disc Four of Season Two. Where the set really shines is in the full disc of supplemental material sure to delight fans and newcomers alike. Hey Abbott!, a 1978 TV special about the duo hosted by Milton Berle, gets a bit schlocky at times, but does a fair job of paying tribute to two of comedy's greatest sons. After tragically losing his son Lou Jr. around his first birthday, Lou formed a charity foundation to benefit underprivileged children that is the subject of the 1948 short film "10,000 Kids and a Cop."

Costello's daughters Chris and Paddy weigh in with an extended interview segment that can be viewed as a whole or by subject area. The two ladies share a wealth of information about their father and "Uncle Bud" that provides some insight into the men behind the legend. Finally, "Lou Costello Home Movies: Holidays and Celebrations" shares some more intimate moments with the Costello family. What's that you say? Not enough? How about a 44 page commemorative book that accompanies the set? The duo's history, supporting cast profiles, and detailed episode summaries are all gathered here in an attractive, bound booklet that is, to be sure, better than your average DVD insert.

Jerry Seinfeld cites Abbott and Costello as two of the inspirations for his career and his award-winning TV series; it's easy to see why. Abbott and Costello were far more than the sum of their parts, leaving behind a significant volume of work that delights and entertains both new viewers and long-time fans to this day.

The Verdict

The Abbott and Costello Show: The Complete Series is guilty of delivering pants-wetting hilarity and an ab workout that puts Billy Blanks to shame!

Give us your feedback!

Did we give The Abbott And Costello Show: The Complete Series a fair trial? yes / no

Share This Review


Follow DVD Verdict


DVD Reviews Quick Index

• DVD Releases
• Recent DVD Reviews
• Search for a DVD review...

Scales of Justice

Judgment: 91

Perp Profile

Studio: E1 Entertainment
Video Formats:
• Full Frame
Audio Formats:
• Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono (English)
Subtitles:
• English (SDH)
Running Time: 1680 Minutes
Release Year: 1952
MPAA Rating: Not Rated
Genres:
• Classic
• Comedy
• Family
• Television

Distinguishing Marks

• Classic Routines
• Home Movies
• Interviews
• TV Special
• Short Film
• Commemorative Book

Accomplices

• IMDb
• Official Site








DVD | Blu-ray | Upcoming DVD Releases | About | Staff | Jobs | Contact | Subscribe | Find us on Google+ | Privacy Policy

Review content copyright © 2010 Kent Dixon; Site design and review layout copyright © 2014 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.