DVD Verdict
Home About News Blu-ray DVD Reviews Upcoming DVD Releases Contest Podcasts Forums Judges Contact  

Case Number 06674

Buy Andromeda: Season Four, Collection Two at Amazon

Andromeda: Season Four, Collection Two

ADV Films // 2003 // 200 Minutes // Not Rated
Reviewed by Judge David Ryan (Retired) // April 27th, 2005

• View Judge Ryan's Dossier
• E-mail Judge Ryan
• Printer Friendly Review


Every purchase you make through these Amazon links supports DVD Verdict's reviewing efforts. Thank you!




 

All Rise...

Appellate Judge Dave Ryan would gladly follow Kevin Sorbo on some damn fool crusade across the universe.

The Charge

"The universe is a dangerous place…"

Opening Statement

Season Four of Andromeda continues with this second quartet of episodes from ADV. These four episodes feature the last Andromeda hurrah of former cast regular Keith Hamilton Cobb (The Young and Restless), who split after Season Three to return to the world of soap operas from whence he came, and the formal introduction / integration of his replacement, Steve Bacic (X2), playing Telemachus Rhade. (Bacic had actually been with the show since the pilot, where he played Dylan's First Officer Gaheris Rhade, whose betrayal of Dylan led to the Andromeda's date with that pesky, time-dilating black hole. He had reprised the Gaheris role a few times during the first season's run of episodes; the Telemachus character—Gaheris's descendant—originally appeared in a Season Two episode.) Unlike the first Season Four collection, this set of episodes is relatively consistent in quality. But it's still a bit difficult to follow these Season Four episodes at times, which unfortunately makes the series somewhat inaccessible for newcomers.

Facts of the Case

Andromeda, based on (literally) some notebook scribblings by Gene Roddenberry, is set in the very, very, very far future. At this point in the show's story, Dylan Hunt (Kevin Sorbo, Hercules: The Legendary Journeys) has successfully restored the pan-galactic Systems Commonwealth, which had done gone and disintegrated on him while he was indisposed. (He and his ship, the Andromeda Ascendant, had accidentally gotten stuck near the event horizon of a black hole, which had the net effect of freezing them in time for 300 years.) He's currently trying to save the universe from the impending threat posed by a nasty race called the Magog, who appear to be the muscle for a sinister supernatural evil called the Abyss. (For further details, please consult the review for Andromeda: Season Four, Collection One.)

The Evidence

This DVD collection contains episodes 406 through 409 of Season Four, presented in their broadcast order:

• "Soon the Nearing Vortex"
The Andromeda stumbles across an interstellar car chase—in this case, a gang of Nietzschean warships pursuing a lone Commonwealth transport ship. The pilot of that Commonwealth ship? Old friend Telemachus Rhade (Bacic). Rhade's cargo is none other than old friend / new enemy / self-proclaimed King of the Nietzscheans Tyr Anasazi (Cobb), who's being…um…transported. Somewhere. Anyhow, Tyr breaks out of his confinement and runs off with the Nietzcheans, while Rhade barely escapes and is picked up by the Andromeda. This puts Hunt and his crew smack in the middle of a messy situation involving Tri-Lorn (Nicholas Lea, The X-Files), who seems to be in cahoots with the semi-evil Collectors, who seem to be in cahoots with Tyr and his Nietzschean allies, who are looking for something called the Route of Ages, which hopefully will save everyone from the Magog World-ship and the Abyss. Or maybe not. It's all a bit hazy.
GRADE: B-

• "The World Turns All Around Her"
In part two of the "Return of Tyr" micro-arc, Dylan and the Andromeda have found the Route of Ages and are ready to pass through it into whatever alternate universe(s) are beyond. Tyr is hot on their tail, however, aided by his new sidekick / lover—Beka Valentine (Lisa Ryder, Forever Knight). Has Beka really gone over to the dark side? What's beyond the Route of Ages? And after four years, can somebody tell us what the heck the deal is with Trance (Laura Bertram)? All questions will be answered by show's end…
GRADE: B+

• "Conduit to Destiny"
A rare piloting mistake by Beka leaves the Andromeda in orbit around Baltria, a sad, repressed little backwater of a world—but a loyal Commonwealth member, too. They're having some prisoner problems (non-stop riots and jailbreaks); Dylan volunteers to help them out. But along the way, he realizes that he's been to Baltria before, during his "old" life 300 years ago, and that he played a role in Baltria's history as well—a role that isn't over yet. Can he save the planet before it's too late? (Of course he can—this is Dylan Hunt!)
GRADE: B+

• "Machinery of the Mind"
The Commonwealth organizes a conference where all the greatest scientists from the three galaxies can gather and discuss the imminent Magog/Abyss threat. Andromeda's own Seamus Zelazny Harper (Gordon Michael Woolvett, Bride of Chucky) is chosen as the keynote speaker, thanks to his up-close-and-personal experience with the Magog. But someone is killing off the scientists one by one. Meanwhile, Dylan has once again been sidetracked by the Collectors, who now hope to recruit him. Can Harper avoid the clutches of whomever is killing the Commonwealth's best and brightest? And will he actually score with busty redhead Doctor / Professor Kor-Kavo (Suzy Joachim, Mother, May I Sleep With Danger?)?
GRADE: A-

Season Four gets a bit more focused in these four episodes. We begin to learn some details about the internal Commonwealth power struggle hinted at in the earlier episodes, and the lines of "good" and "evil" in that struggle are nicely blurred for us. Tyr's return, although brief, is certainly welcome; the show just isn't the same without him. Yes, he was an arrogant, egomaniacal jerk, but he was also a fascinating character, and he served as an effective dramatic counterpoint to Dylan's near-saintly perfection. On the whole, these episodes just feel like they have more of a point than the first five shows did.

As always, the show truly begins and ends with Kevin Sorbo. I've said it before, I'll say it again: never has there been a man more suited to play a larger-than-life heroic character like this, with the possible exception of the late Christopher Reeve. Sorbo's gregarious charm and utter lack of pretentiousness are clearly the touchstones on which the other actors base their performances, which is one of the things that makes the show so strong. And it is very strong in the acting department—this is a cast that can take a script and bring out its wit and humor without descending into annoying farce. It's writing that has been this show's occasional downfall.

The writing isn't perfect here—but it's far from horrible. The real flaw with the Tyr mini-arc shows is the attempt to wrap up Tyr's entire multi-year story in two hours. It feels rushed, a lot of information is thrown at the viewer in a very short time, and Cobb is never given much of an opportunity to put in a full-on, scenery-chewing Tyr spectacle. On the other hand, the producers knew that Cobb would only be back for these two shows, and at least made the attempt to tie up all of Tyr's loose ends for the fans. I can respect that.

The best of the lot, though, are the two non-Tyr episodes. "Conduit to Destiny" is a cleverly-written tale that throws just enough curveballs at you to keep things interesting, while "Machinery of the Mind" is one of the wittiest Andromeda episodes I've seen.

The picture quality is just as good on these discs as on the first set—no surprise there. Steve Bacic is profiled in this set's "Meet the Cast" featurette; he's a very likeable and articulate guy. The usual complement of deleted scenes is included; for the most part, these are very small snips of dialogue (almost always involving Harper, too). They don't really add that much to the viewer's enjoyment. In fact, it's clear why all these scenes were cut—they're all examples of poor exposition. (The audience rarely enjoys being lectured.) In lieu of a production featurette, this set has an interview with Andromeda producer Bob Engels, who talks about some "big picture" issues involving the show and its production. It's interesting, but arguably not as interesting as it should have been. Finally, there's a fun blooper reel focusing on Lisa Ryder, who appears to be just as spunky as her character.

The Rebuttal Witnesses

Poor Steve Bacic really had no chance to truly replace Keith Cobb. Bacic is, basically, a male model with some acting skill (just like Kevin Sorbo). Cobb is a highly-trained actor with model looks. Cobb played Tyr Anasazi with the kind of intensity you usually expect from someone like Marlon Brando or George C. Scott. Love him or hate him, he's a memorable actor. Bacic is far from incompetent, but it's very clear that Telemachus Rhade was very much a work-in-progress at this point. Bacic tends to speak too quickly, and occasionally misemphasizes lines. (But those muscles sure look good.) Thankfully, Bacic eventually relaxed and got in touch with his inner Nietszchean, and his performances as Telemachus Rhade improved dramatically. But in this set, he's a bit of a lead weight. (A really, really likeable guy, though. Canadians! Gotta love 'em.)

The sound mix on these sets is puzzlingly bad. It's a Dolby 2.0 stereo mix, but a very weak one that tends to leave dialogue frustratingly difficult to understand. I think it's safe to assume that the entire cast of a major television action/drama isn't mumbling all the time; therefore, it's got to be a flaw in the mix. Adding to the frustration is the fact that the repeats of the show on the Sci-Fi Channel sound just fine (and also appear to be in 2.0 Pro Logic Surround). I just don't get it.

Finally, there's the price point of these Andromeda sets. Forty bucks for four episodes is usurious, especially when the sound stinks. It's a shame, too—this is a show that many people would probably enjoy, if they just had an easy way to get on board with it. Instead, these sets are priced such that only the very loyal—or the very stupid—will do anything but rent.

Closing Statement

Andromeda is a highly underrated show that should be more popular than it is. As its fifth and final season wraps up, here's hoping more people discover (as I have) the quality storytelling and acting that can be found in past episodes of the show. If you're completely new to the show, though, I recommend you start with some episodes from the first season. Picking this story up at this point, well into the fourth season, is possible, but you'll enjoy the shows more if you're familiar with some of the backstory.

The Verdict

The only guilty party here is whoever came up with that retail price. Everyone else is free to go. And I still miss Purple Trance.

Give us your feedback!

Did we give Andromeda: Season Four, Collection Two a fair trial? yes / no

Share This Review


Follow DVD Verdict


Other Reviews You Might Enjoy

• Swordfish (Blu-Ray)
• Exit Speed
• Firestorm (1998)
• Lethal Weapon 3

DVD Reviews Quick Index

• DVD Releases
• Recent DVD Reviews
• Search for a DVD review...

Scales of Justice

Video: 94
Audio: 70
Extras: 80
Acting: 83
Story: 87
Judgment: 85

Perp Profile

Studio: ADV Films
Video Formats:
• 1.85:1 Anamorphic
Audio Formats:
• Dolby Digital 2.0 Stereo (English)
Subtitles:
• None
Running Time: 200 Minutes
Release Year: 2003
MPAA Rating: Not Rated
Genres:
• Action
• Science Fiction
• Television

Distinguishing Marks

• Meet the Cast: Steve Bacic (Telemachus Rhade)
• Behind-the-Scenes: Producer Bob Engels
• Bio: Bob Engels
• Lisa Ryder's Bloopers and Gags
• Deleted Scenes
• TV Promos








DVD | Blu-ray | Upcoming DVD Releases | About | Staff | Jobs | Contact | Subscribe | Find us on Google+ | Privacy Policy

Review content copyright © 2005 David Ryan; Site design and review layout copyright © 2014 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.