DVD Verdict
Home About News Blu-ray DVD Reviews Upcoming DVD Releases Contest Podcasts Forums Judges Contact  

Case Number 16897: Small Claims Court

Buy Dollhouse: Season One at Amazon

Dollhouse: Season One

Fox // 2009 // 641 Minutes // Not Rated
Reviewed by Appellate Judge Jennifer Malkowski (Retired) // July 27th, 2009

• View Appellate Judge Malkowski's Dossier
• E-mail Appellate Judge Malkowski
• Printer Friendly Review


Every purchase you make through these Amazon links supports DVD Verdict's reviewing efforts. Thank you!




 

All Rise...

Appellate Judge Jennifer Malkowski would like to play with Echo in the Dollhouse—if it weren't so morally disturbing.

Editor's Note

Our review of Dollhouse: Season Two (Blu-Ray), published October 25th, 2010, is also available.

The Charge

"Did I fall asleep?"

dollhouse eliza dushku

The Case

Television auteur Joss Whedon's latest series, Dollhouse, spends most of its first few moments providing viewers with a high-speed motorcycle race and ass-level shots of a hot young actress dancing in a dress that would be more accurately described as a shirt. While casual channel-flippers might at that point have dismissed this new series as more from Fox's usual bag of tricks and kept flipping, connoisseurs of smart TV knew to be patient. After all, Whedon had learned on his previous shows Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel, and Firefly that if you want to write complicated narrative arcs and ultra-quirky dialogue, you should add plenty of action and some T&A to keep the network happy. Since his shows seem to be in perpetual danger of cancellation lately, I'm happy to twiddle my thumbs through a motorcycle race every now and again, if it keeps his work on the air—and frankly, I'm more than happy to watch his leading lady dance in a shirt-dress. As it turned out with Dollhouse, patience would be necessary for longer than many of us Whedonites had hoped, but by midseason his new TV venture began to prove worthy of its heritage. The fantastic second half of Dollhouse: Season One more than justifies its purchase, and will hopefully bring viewers back for the second season now that the show has narrowly escaped cancellation.

Let's get a handle on the wacky premise and the individual episodes before I sing its praises further. Spoiler Alert! I'll be discussing plot points through the end of Season One:

The leading lady in the shirt-dress is of course Eliza Dushku, who worked with Whedon previously as Faith, Buffy the Vampire Slayer's bad girl "other" slayer. On Dollhouse she gets to play the bad girl, the good girl, and just about every girl in between because she's cast as Echo, a young woman who has signed away five years of her life and agreed to let an underground organization "imprint" her with various personalities suited to various missions. The organization hires her out to clients for a big price tag, and the clients may want anything from your standard kinky sex partner to an expert hostage negotiator. When she's not out on one of these "engagements," Echo's brain is wiped clean of these personalities and she's reset to a state of vacant nonchalance. At these times, she's free to relax in the Dollhouse, a calm and opulent facility where she and other "dolls" like her spend their off-duty hours getting massages, exercising, and eating five-star cuisine.

dollhouse eliza dushku

Echo is joined in this indoor Eden by a few other dolls that become prominent characters: Sierra (Dichen Lachman, Bled), Victor (Enver Gjokaj), and November (Miracle Laurie). Since I can't describe the non-existent personalities of these characters (and for once that's not a criticism but merely a condition of the premise!), we'll move on to the ladies and gentlemen running this bizarre business. Boastful nerd boy Topher (Fran Kranz, The Village) is there to imprint the dolls with their engagement personalities, and also to crack wise and spit out all the sci-fi exposition. When the imprint is complete and Echo sets off for her engagement, Echo's "handler" Boyd (Harry Lennix, State of Play) accompanies her and tries to keep her out of danger. Whenever he fails, Dr. Saunders (Amy Acker, Angel) is at hand to patch Echo up. They all answer to Adelle DeWitt (Olivia Williams, Rushmore), the icy British boss lady who oversees the Dollhouse from her impressive corner office upstairs.

Outside of the Dollhouse, FBI Agent Paul Ballard (Tahmoh Penikett, Battlestar Galactica) is determined to prove that the secret facility is more than an urban legend. He wants to rescue the dolls, especially Echo—whom he knows by her real, pre-Dollhouse name, Caroline. Also on the outside is Alpha, a former doll who broke out of the facility, but paused to carve up the faces of several other dolls and staff members on his way out. Signs crop up that he might be alive and plotting further revenge.

Dollhouse's first season is comprised of the following twelve episodes, plus two unaired episodes I'll get to later on:

• "Ghost" (with commentary by Joss Whedon and Eliza Dushku)
In the series premiere (at least, the one Fox decided to air), we're introduced to the workings of the Dollhouse, as well as the guy trying to bring it down, Agent Ballard. Echo is charged with recovering a businessman's kidnapped daughter, but things take a turn for the even less pleasant when it turns out that her negotiator persona, Eleanor Penn, was kidnapped by the same child molester years earlier.
Caroline, in a home movie: "What can I say? I want to do everything. Is that too much to ask?"
Grade: B-

• "The Target"
Echo's engagement seems like an outdoorsy adventure date—until her woodsman client starts hunting her with a bow and arrow. Interspersed with this story, we get a closer look at the science-augmented bond between Echo and Boyd, and also flashbacks to the aftermath of Alpha's rampage.
Client to Echo: "You really are the perfect woman."
Grade: B

• "Stage Fright"
When a pop diva is targeted by a murderous fan, Echo becomes a backup singer with an unconscious bodyguard imprint to watch her back. Ballard seeks information on the Dollhouse from a Russian mobster.
Echo to the diva: "You can fire me, but bitch don't think you can take me."
Grade: C

• "Gray Hour"
In the middle of an art heist engagement, Echo's badass super-thief imprint goes terribly wrong. Back at the Dollhouse, the staff starts to notice Echo, Sierra, and Victor "grouping."
Sierra: "I try to be my best."
Grade: B

• "True Believer"
To help a federal agency infiltrate a suspect religious cult, Echo becomes a spiritual blind girl with sneaky camera eyes. While she's away, an unexpected crisis arises at the Dollhouse when Victor gets an erection—or a "man reaction" as squeamish Topher prefers to call it.
Topher, seeing Victor: "I gotta go. Something…came up."
Grade: C+

• "Man on the Street" (with commentary by Joss Whedon)
Ballard finally comes face to face with Caroline/Echo—under two very different circumstances. In the Dollhouse, the staff must investigate the possibility that Sierra has been raped by someone on the inside. Scattered among these plots are a selection of "man on the street" interviews that get L.A. citizens' reactions to the Dollhouse urban legend.
Dominic: "You played a good hand, ma'am."
Adelle: "I played a very bad hand very well. There is a distinction."
Grade: A

• "Echoes"
A team of dolls and Dollhouse staff are sent to a college campus to stop the spread of a drug that causes people to lose their inhibitions. Predictably, our characters get infected and—you guessed it—lose their inhibitions. But the dolls are affected differently and begin remembering their pasts, including Echo, who was once a student on this campus.
Echo: "We're not gonna have to fight, are we? Because I don't really even know how to make a fist."
Grade: B+

• "Needs"
In the middle of the night, a room full of dolls "wake up" in their pods scared and confused about where they are and why they're trapped in "five-star floor coffins." They work together to plan an escape and investigate their former lives.
Adelle to Caroline: "You wanted to forget."
Grade: A

• "A Spy in the House of Love"
We look in on a day in the life of each of our four main dolls on assignment: Victor is imprinted as a dashing romantic for a mysterious client, November plays house with Ballard as Mellie and they have a surprising conversation, and Echo and Sierra are each tasked with sniffing out a spy in the Dollhouse.
Dominic to Echo: "…someday you'll be erasing them. And even after all this, they won't see it coming."
Grade: A-

• "Haunted"
When a rich and paranoid friend of Adelle's dies, the personality and memories she stored with the Dollhouse are imprinted onto Echo's body so that she can attend her own funeral and solve her own murder. Meanwhile, Topher gives himself an elaborate birthday present and Ballard crosses a line with Mellie.
Boyd: "I guess Topher can make friends."
Grade: A+

• "Briar Rose"
Having discovered the location of the Dollhouse, Ballard finds and abducts a man who helped designed it and knows how to get in. Ballard's journey inside the Dollhouse, though, is riddled with unpleasant surprises.
Echo: "It's okay to get rescued if you're young, or small, or you just can't do it yourself."
Grade: A-

• "Omega"
With a homemade wiping chair, a sack of imprint files, and a kidnapped stranger Alpha implements his complex evil scheme to make Echo his perfect mate. Ballard helps the Dollhouse staff in their attempts to get Echo back, and we're treated to illuminating flashbacks of Alpha's original stint as a doll.
Echo to Caroline: "I'm nobody. I'm just the porch light waitin' for you."
Grade: A

An early exchange between Adelle and Caroline (soon to become Echo) in Dollhouse's first episode feels representative somehow of both the central philosophical concern of the series and of the fraught relationship between Whedon and the Fox network through which Dollhouse was born. Adelle has a contract in hand and is trying to convince Caroline to join the Dollhouse:

Adelle: "I'm talking about a clean slate."
Caroline: "You ever try and clean an actual slate? You always see what was on it before."

Philosophically, this dialogue sets up the show's fascinating main question: can the Dollhouse truly wipe away a person's identity, or is there something intrinsic to each human being that will survive such a process? But on a less cerebral plane, this dialogue also resonates with the behind-the-scenes production of the series. Whedon and Fox's agreement to make Dollhouse together seemed to represent a clean slate after the network broke a lot of hearts (Whedon's included, I think) by canceling his previous series Firefly after only one season. In accordance with Caroline's prediction though, Dollhouse fans did see too much of "what was on it before" with this slate: creative disagreements between Whedon and Fox about storylines and a dreadful Friday night time slot, in particular. These echoes of problems past resulted in low viewing numbers for this first season and also a marked difference in quality between the early episodes and the late ones.

Reportedly because of Fox's insistence, the first five episodes of the season are stand-alone outings, what we might call "engagement of the week" adventures. Echo gets a new mission and a new imprint, she does something (maybe) thrilling for 40-odd minutes, and then she returns to the Dollhouse ready for next week's similarly isolated mission. While most television used to be this way, we've entered a TV age in the past decade that's much more focused on serial narratives—complex stories that carry over and build from episode to episode. That's been a change for the better, in my view, and Whedon has already proven himself a master of the complex serial format with the later seasons of Buffy. Dollhouse cries out to be that kind of show, and it's a bit painful to watch it floundering in its first five episodes, as even for one-shot stories some of these are mediocre.

Then, to use the language of the series, it's as if Dollhouse sits itself down in the chair and gets a whole new imprint in "Man on the Street," the Whedon-penned sixth episode. "Did I fall asleep?" Yes, and we nearly did, too—but then you woke up! In this episode, Ballard's scavenging for clues about the Dollhouse finally kicks into high gear with a duo of fantastic encounters with Echo. The second features an expertly choreographed fight scene that's big fun to watch as well as information tantalizing enough to get us more curious about those arranging the dolls in their house: Echo tells Ballard that there are over 20 Dollhouses operating around the world and that "The Dollhouse deals in fantasy. That is their business, but not their purpose." Sounds like mystery enough for a second season and then some, no? His first encounter with Echo, earlier in the episode, was equally impressive in a different way: it demonstrated that Dollhouse actually could create totally compelling, isolated engagement-of-the-week stories, too. In this scenario, Ballard busts in on an engagement in which Echo is imprinted as the wife of internet mogul Joel Mynor. With his romantic date ruined, Mynor sits down with Ballard to explain what his seemingly seedy scenario was really all about and to make Ballard question some of his own motivations for investigating the Dollhouse. He accuses Ballard:

"You have a fantasy. We all do. We need it to survive. And I think your fantasy is about my Rebecca [Echo]…Then the brave little FBI agent whisked her away from the cash-wielding losers and restored her true identity, and she fell in love with him."

This little chat is one of the season's most inspired scenes, peppered with wonderful lines of dialogue, benefitting from funny-man Patton Oswalt's (Ratatouille) great guest performance as Mynor, and offering up a surprisingly moving engagement scenario that pays off sweetly at the end of the episode.

Once Dollhouse finds its footing with this episode, the rest of the season comes alive in every way. Again, even single-episode stories no longer seem to be the problem they were earlier in the season; my favorite episode thus far, "Haunted," fits that profile. Here, the writers set up one of those great sci-fi premises that uses imagined technology to give us an illuminating human story that couldn't be told without it. In this case, a dead woman gets a loaner body with her own memories and can witness how people she knew react to her death. It's a common, if morbid, fantasy, but one that Adelle reveals to have dark possibilities:

Margaret: "See my own funeral? Who wouldn't want that?"
Adelle: "To see what the world really thought of us? To count out the number who love us?"

Of course, this dark side of life after death rears its head in a big way in "Haunted," but the writers and actors balance out the true sadness and poignancy of the scenario by writing Margaret as a particularly brisk and chipper dead woman, and by unfolding a fun little murder mystery (and also by including a great, character-developing subplot about Topher's birthday treat). This pitch-perfect engagement-of-the-week episode seems to be just a way to pass the time before the big finale, but it's the sleeper hit of Dollhouse: Season One and not to be missed.

While I've highlighted the quality of these two episodes, almost everything from "Man on the Street" through "Omega" is skillfully written and compelling. A big part of what sustains the momentum of this stretch of episodes is the surprisingly good performance that Dushku delivers in Dollhouse. I don't mean to slight her previous work—she was great as Faith on Buffy—but I was skeptical about whether she could pull off such a ridiculously demanding role. Indeed, it would be difficult to write a part more challenging than this one. During the course of these episodes, Dushku has to inhabit the base characters of pre-Dollhouse Caroline and Echo the doll, as well as more than a dozen short-term imprints, including personalities as varied as a kidnapping negotiator, an arctic midwife, a safe cracker, a social worker, a dominatrix, and a blind religious fanatic.

dollhouse eliza dushku

Though she stumbles on occasion with some of these roles—the negotiator in "Ghost" being the most egregious case—Dushku should be commended for putting so much energy and charisma into these various characters. Fortunately, she does her best work with her two most important personas: Caroline and Echo. As the woman who signed away five years of her life, Dushku's Caroline remains something of a mystery by season's end, but in her intermittent appearances she is both sympathetic and interesting—particularly when she yearns to save her fellow dolls in "Needs" and when she has a fascinating conversation/confrontation with herself (hard to explain!). As Echo, the woman Caroline is forced to become, Dushku exhibits a talent for playing the kind of extreme vacancy coupled with sweetness that Whedon seems to enjoy assigning to his lead actresses (remember the Buffybot?). The hefty challenge for both writers and actors with these doll characters is, how do you create character development or consistency when the dolls' minds are wiped clean after each episode? Dushku gives the writers a big helping hand by ably layering a bit of individuality into Echo's blankness. Like the not-so-clean slate Caroline describes that still reveals "what was on it before," Dushku makes Echo a palimpsest, retaining just the smallest traces of the women she has been but forgotten while she wanders around the Dollhouse, wide-eyed and empty. The cathartic release after all this vacant helplessness arrives in the season finale when Dushku comes to embody all of her past imprints at once. Apparently when you add up all these personalities you get one truly awesome individual, because this character crackles on screen. Filled with self-assurance and moral righteousness, she whacks the knife-happy bad guy in the head with a pipe and convincingly explains to him why he's such a bastard: "And don't hand me any more of your crap about you being some superior, ascended being. To ascend to anything, at minimum you do not cut up women!"

dollhouse eliza dushku

And speaking of that knife-happy bad guy, I want to touch on a few other great performances in Dollhouse: Season One, starting with Alan Tudyk's Alpha. Both in pretending to be the stoner environmental designer Stephen Kepler and in embodying the psychotic ex-doll Alpha, Tudyk excels, first bringing lots of comedy and then somehow retaining that humor and mixing it with a generous helping of terror. Tudyk and the writers take particular comedic advantage of the character's 48 personalities which compete for dominance inside his brain, as when he threatens his captives and promises: "I'm not fooling. He's not fooling. We're not bluffing. I'm bluffing. But the rest of us, we mean business." Tudyk's stay is brief, but of the regular cast the standout for me is Olivia Williams as Adelle. Her delightfully sharp wit and overwhelming Britishness made many of her lines the most memorable, such as this curt exchange when Boyd gravely walks into her office with a criticism in "Haunted":

Boyd: "Eternal life."
Adelle: "Nice adjective, excellent noun. Is there more?"

Of course Whedon and his writing staff are experts at building up imposing characters like Adelle and then breaking them down with inevitable hilarity. For Adelle, this moment comes when she's infected with the inhibition-losing drug in "Echoes." Conversing with the also-infected Topher (another source of reliable wit and laughs on the series), she loses her composure considerably as they try to work through a new development in the engagement:

Adelle: "What the sun-dappled hell is Echo doing at Fremont?"
Topher: "That's got nothing to do with the drug, which means our problems are huge and indomitable."
Adelle: "Oooh. I could eat that word. Or a crisp. Do you have any crisps?"
Topher: "You haven't seen my drawer of inappropriate starches?!?"

Further hilarity and a mountain of inappropriate starches follow:

dollhouse eliza dushku

There are plenty of wonderful aspects of Dollhouse—nearly all the performers, the beautiful and dynamic Dollhouse set, the opening credits and theme music, the moral questions it raises—and I heartily recommend the season, despite its slow start. Fox has ordered a second season and Whedon has certainly left tons of narrative possibilities open for further development. But as relieved and grateful as I was to hear that Fox had renewed Dollhouse for more episodes, I'm wise enough not to expect a clean slate…

Now that we've had the good news in this review (Dollhouse is great), let's get to the bad news. The screener copies of Dollhouse: Season One that Fox sent out for review so little resemble the DVD set you'll be able to buy that there's little I can tell you about technical quality or bonus features. Though the Dolby 5.1 soundtrack was robust on my screener discs, the picture quality was marred by compression, resulting in lots of unsightly artifacts that made the ever-so-pretty Dollhouse a lot less fun to look at. It's doubtful that such large-scale image problems will exist on the finished set, but I can't tell you anything about its picture quality. More disappointing is my inability to review the bonus features, which will reportedly include two unaired episodes: the scrapped pilot "Echo" and the post-"Omega" thirteenth episode, "Epitaph One." Since these are the features fans are most excited about, it's unfortunate that I can't report on their quality. Our screener discs also left out the deleted scenes and featurettes that the finished set will include. From what I've been able to glean, there aren't any extras exclusive to the Blu-ray release, so buyers will be shelling out the extra bucks for a presumed upgrade in picture and sound quality only. The features I did have access to on these screener discs were two commentary tracks, on "Ghost" and "Man on the Street." Other TV releases have raised the stakes on commentary tracks lately, with Mad Men: Season Two, for example, offering two per episode, so this little duo felt a bit insufficient in quantity. The quality, however, was quite good on both. For "Ghost," Dushku and Whedon banter charmingly and humorously. Dushku drools over several of the actors who appear on screen (as does Whedon, actually) and Whedon pokes fun at the show's lackluster popularity: when Echo repeats her line "Did I fall asleep?" after having her brain wiped, Whedon says, "Our catch phrase. 'America: you'll fall asleep!' We had to work on that campaign." Doing a solo commentary for "Man on the Street," Whedon is characteristically insightful throughout. When Ballard sprints to save his girlfriend from a Dollhouse assassin, Whedon comments: "This is more like the kind of show I like to do, where the hero comes to save the day and the girl has already saved it for him." That's the kind of show I like to watch, too, and Joss Whedon has my eternal gratitude for creating so many of them, including Dollhouse.

The Verdict

Dollhouse the series is not guilty, but the court has insufficient information to properly rule on Fox's DVD release of Dollhouse: Season One.

Give us your feedback!

Did we give Dollhouse: Season One a fair trial? yes / no

Share This Review


Follow DVD Verdict


Other Reviews You Might Enjoy

• Sins Of The Father
• The Europeans
• The Marine 2
• Losing Isaiah

DVD Reviews Quick Index

• DVD Releases
• Recent DVD Reviews
• Search for a DVD review...

Scales of Justice

Judgment: 93

Perp Profile

Studio: Fox
Video Formats:
• 1.78:1 Anamorphic
Audio Formats:
• Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround (English)
Subtitles:
• English
• French
• Portuguese
• Spanish
Running Time: 641 Minutes
Release Year: 2009
MPAA Rating: Not Rated
Genres:
• Action
• Drama
• Science Fiction
• Television

Distinguishing Marks

• Unaired Episodes
• Commentaries
• Deleted Scenes
• Featurettes

Accomplices

• IMDb
• Official Site
• Whedonesque.com








DVD | Blu-ray | Upcoming DVD Releases | About | Staff | Jobs | Contact | Subscribe | Find us on Google+ | Privacy Policy

Review content copyright © 2009 Jennifer Malkowski; Site design and review layout copyright © 2014 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.