Judge Daryl Loomis makes dioramas depicting rooms filled with historic dioramas.
The dead talk; we just don't like what they say.
Humans are a species obsessed with death. That's come out in many different ways, over and over again, spanning millennia and cultures. Today, this is as pronounced as ever, with shows like CSI and Law and Order topping the ratings over decades (heck, even a maritime forensics show gets multiple spinoffs, and that's just crazy), and true crime novels taking up major shelf space in stores. With all this interest, it seems only natural that somebody would create a documentary looking at the realities of forensics, and director Susan Marks has stepped up to the plate with her piece, Of Dolls and Murder.
Marks weaves together two related threads in her film. The first, less interesting part focuses on real life forensic science and its relation to people's expectations based on their favorite television shows. She follows around some Baltimore detectives, who have been immortalized twice on the small screen in Homicide: Life on the Streets and The Wire, and speaks to one of the producers of CSI to discover that their understanding of those unrealistic expectations are essentially the same. While reality dictates that investigations last months and many cases are never solved, let alone solved clean in under an hour, the heightened interest is a net positive for forensics.
That may not be the most compelling topic in the world for me, but the second thread makes the movie work. Here, Marks discusses Frances Glessner Lee, a name few have heard of, but who made major contributions to forensic studies. An heiress who was barred from going to college at the end of the 19th Century, Lee took to building dollhouses. These weren't ordinary playthings, though; they were obsessively detailed renditions of murder scenes. She called them "nutshells" and, filled with subtle clues that point to who and what caused the crime, they became teaching tools for detectives across the country that are still used to this day for the same purpose. They are amazing pieces and beautifully shot, but what takes the cake is that, describing the scenes as we view them, with all the flourish he can muster in the purple prose, is none other than John Waters.
I could listen to John Waters all day and his work is what really makes the movie, because the two parts are not woven together as tightly as I would like. The discussion of real life forensics left me wishing for another nutshell and another reading from Waters. It's a solid, but uneven documentary that is still worth watching for fans of detective shows, and especially to see the work of Francis Glessner Lee which, for me, was a first.
Of Dolls and Murder arrives in a nice edition from MVD. The anamorphic image is solid, but not perfect. The colors are strong and the detail, especially in the nutshell displays, is quite fine. Some of the other footage, including most of the dramatizations, look a little murky, though, but it's never that bad. The sound could certainly be bolder in the surround channels, which have very little going on, but the mix does its job and the mix sounds clear enough. Extras include an audio commentary with the director and members of the production team and a few short featurettes that give a little more background into the life of Frances Glessner Lee.
Overall, this is a worthy disc for a movie that I can easily recommend. I wish there was a little more detail about Lee and less discussion of the expectations created by current forensics-based television dramas, but given that it's a subject that generates so much interest and it enlightens viewers on the relatively obscure nutshells, people will likely eat this movie up.
Give us your feedback!
What's "fair"? Whether positive or negative, our reviews should be unbiased, informative, and critique the material on its own merits.
Other Reviews You Might Enjoy
Scales of Justice
Studio: MVD Visual
Review content copyright © 2012 Daryl Loomis; Site design and review layout copyright © 2015 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.