Appellate Judge James A. Stewart takes two more spins through Gamera's Japan.
Our review of Gamera: Ultimate Collection, Volume 2 (Blu-ray), published June 8th, 2014, is also available.
"The enemy from space was about to cause a series of great disasters."
Giant turtle Gamera takes two more spins through the Japanese landscape in this Gamera Double Feature.
Facts of the Case
The two movies share one disc:
• Gamera vs. Zigra
• Gamera: Super Monster
Gamera vs. Zigra is pretty much what you'd expect: kids outwitting a monster's henchwoman while Gamera takes on the monster itself. There are high stakes, since Zigra wants to blow up cities and dine on earthlings, but the movie's harmless enough that even kids aren't likely to take that seriously. Kids are warned about polluting the oceans. There's an amusing scene near the end as Gamera uses the defeated Zigra as a xylophone.
You might be encouraged in the opening moments of Gamera: Super Monster if you notice that the evil alien spaceship looks a little less cheesy than in past Gamera films. That would only set you up for disappointment, since the movie turns out to be recycling footage from past Gamera films, including that xylophone scene from Zigra. Mach Fumiake gets two moments of heroism, but the spacewomen mostly end up transforming into spacewomen only to quickly zap themselves back into human guise to avoid getting zapped by the Zanon ship; they're generally there to introduce scenes of Gamera in action on some kind of telescreen and create some illusion of a new story. The lack of new material and the fact that the spacewomen don't actually do much make it tedious.
I noticed on the English translation of Zigra that the year changed from 1971 to 1985, and the kids were visiting Japan from New York. The acting seems to be overdone more than in the Japanese soundtrack, so I'd give a nod toward watching with subtitles. The voices on Super Monster were actually English; in one scene, the heroic spacewoman's stiff upper lip speech is a little more dramatic than the one in the subtitles.
Aside from some generally cheap effects, I didn't see any problems with the picture. There are a few photo bonus features: publicity galleries for both movies, and behind-the-scenes photos for Zigra showing the rather human scale of the monsters, making them the most interesting feature. All three photo galleries are brief; fans will want more. The case contains a nice bio of Gamera, though.
The Rebuttal Witnesses
At least there's a fresh-sounding arrangement of the "Gamera March," if only on an electric organ, in Gamera: Super Monster.
If you really just wanted a highlights reel of Gamera in battle and have a high tolerance for silliness, you could like Super Monster.
The Gamera series sticks closely to formula, but these double features show that the execution varied. Neither is a cinema classic, but Zigra meets the typical expectations of the formula better. It's a good deal for Gamera fans if you get a good price.
Gamera's guilty of uneven performances, but forgiven.
Give us your feedback!
What's "fair"? Whether positive or negative, our reviews should be unbiased, informative, and critique the material on its own merits.
Scales of Justice, Gamera Vs. Zigra
Perp Profile, Gamera Vs. Zigra
Studio: Shout! Factory
Distinguishing Marks, Gamera Vs. Zigra
• Image Galleries
Scales of Justice, Gamera: Super Monster
Perp Profile, Gamera: Super Monster
Studio: Shout! Factory
Distinguishing Marks, Gamera: Super Monster
• Image Gallery
Review content copyright © 2011 James A. Stewart; Site design and review layout copyright © 2015 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.