"Well, I'll be jiggered."
The first film to be released by David O. Selznick's new company—Selznick International—was Little Lord Fauntleroy in early 1936. The Victorian era classic by Frances Hodgson Burnett had been popular for many years and was another of Selznick's childhood favourites. The screen rights were actually owned by Mary Pickford at the time, as she had starred in a silent version which had been one of her biggest successes, but she consented to Selznick's remake as his pictures would now be released through her company, United Artists.
Little Lord Fauntleroy has never looked particularly great on home video in VHS and was not made available on LD. Anchor Bay has now brought the title to DVD as part of its cycle of Selznick title releases.
Facts of the Case
A young widow and her son Ceddie live in 1880s Brooklyn, following the death of her husband, an English army captain. The captain's father, the Earl of Dorincourt, had denounced his son for marrying an American and had refused to have any contact with the young wife. At age nine, however, Ceddie is summoned to England to assume the title of Lord Fauntleroy, the Earl's successor. Ceddie is not particularly inclined to accept the title, especially knowing that his best friend, the local grocer Mr. Hobbs, feels all aristocrats to be pompous and unkind.
Ceddie's mother (whom he calls "Dearest") recognizes the great opportunity and convinces Ceddie to go to England, even though it will mean that she and Ceddie must live there in adjacent but separate houses because of the Earl of Dorincourt's dislike for her. Ceddie meets the Earl and soon begins to charm him through his politeness, courtesy and common sense. The Earl starts to overcome his poor reputation for being uncaring and distant as a result, and the two are soon almost inseparable.
At this point, a counter-claim for the title of Lord Fauntleroy is made by another woman and her ill-mannered son Tom. She claims that she was married to the Earl's eldest son and that her Tom thus takes precedence over Ceddie as the true heir to the Fauntleroy title. The Earl of Dorincourt is floored by this possibility and it seems that there is no way out until help comes from an unexpected source.
By the mid-1930s, David O. Selznick was developing a reputation for top-notch adaptations of the classics to film, having clicked with such efforts as David Copperfield, Anna Karenina and A Tale of Two Cities—all in 1935 while still with MGM. So his desire to do an adaptation of "Little Lord Fauntleroy" was no surprise, even if some people had apprehensions due to the dated nature of the story and the image that the name "Fauntleroy" by then invoked—that of a sissy in a velvet suit.
Selznick's best casting decision was to secure Freddie Bartholemew's services from MGM to play Ceddie. Bartholemew was quite an outstanding young actor who could convey the various nuances of the character. He always had an aristocratic air about him that was obviously essential for the role at hand, but he could get down and dirty when needed. In Little Lord Fauntleroy, he needed to early on in order to deal with a gang of neighbourhood bullies who try to take his new bicycle. His willingness to mix it up if ultimately needed even though he'd rather reason his way out of it brings a dimension to the character that lifts it above so many others of its kind. Bartholemew was able to convey that dimension believably.
To play Dearest, Selznick enticed Dolores Costello to return to the screen. Costello had been a reliable leading lady of silent films with a few roles in early sound films and was for a time married to John Barrymore (hence her cast listing as Dolores Costello Barrymore). As with the role of Ceddie, that of Dearest was more than skin deep. The surface, or outer, appearance of the character was one of reliance on others (somewhat akin to David Copperfield's Dora), but that hid a strength of purpose that was mainly manifest in how she deals with the Earl. Costello balanced the two aspects most effectively.
For the rest of the roles, Selznick assembled a fine cast of familiar faces. For the American component of the story, we have Guy Kibbee as Mr. Hobbs, Mickey Rooney as Dick (Ceddie's pal of the streets), Una O'Connor as Mary, and Jessie Ralph as the apple woman. For the British component, the Hollywood English contingent was out in force: C. Aubrey Smith superb as the Earl of Dorincourt, Henry Stephenson as the Earl's solicitor Havisham, and E.E. Clive as Sir Harry Lorridaile. Hollywood nearly always succeeded in giving a real British feel (if somewhat idealized) to the films that required it and it did so here again most emphatically.
The film is competently directed by John Cromwell from a screenplay by Hugh Walpole with the usual contributions by Selznick himself. The final production cost was a little over $500,000—somewhat high for the time—but the film was well received and apparently returned a nice profit. It deserved to. Watching the final product is an entirely enjoyable experience. The story is solid; the acting top-notch—all contributing to a general feeling at the end of having spent a pleasant hour and forty minutes among friends.
Anchor Bay continues a fine run of nice-looking DVDs of David O. Selznick's productions. Little Lord Fauntleroy is just a shade below most of the others in image quality. The film is presented full-frame in its original aspect ratio and has 24 scene selections. The DVD is certainly far superior to any previous video rendition, but there are scratches and speckling occasionally that are noticeable and drop the DVD's image rating somewhat. There is also a softness to the image from time to time although shadow detail for the most part is quite acceptable. The sound on the disc is just passable. Clarity is no problem, but there is an underlying hiss that detracts from any substantial amplification.
The Rebuttal Witnesses
Perhaps the only part of Little Lord Fauntleroy that may pose difficulties for a modern audience is the beginning. The name of Ceddie's mother (Dearest) and their relationship is almost too precious and can convey the feeling that all that's to come is just going to be too syrupy to enjoy. Don't allow that first few minutes to put you off; patience is very much rewarded in this film.
Anchor Bay gives us another fairly barebones effort supplement-wise. There is a theatrical trailer and a preview trailer that are fine. There's also something called a TV Bumper. I had no idea what that was. Well, it turns out to be a single period-image with the name of the film superimposed that TV stations inserted at the beginning of a commercial break while they gave a voice-over announcing that the film would continue afterwards. Big thrill!
I give a strong recommendation to Little Lord Fauntleroy. It's a film that can be equally enjoyed by adults and children—real family entertainment. Anchor Bay's DVD presents the film in a quite workable form and substantially better than any previous video incarnations. Too bad, it didn't see fit to treat the title a little more expansively in terms of supplementary material. So little effort is required to add interesting production and cast and crew information as a minimum.
The defendant is fully acquitted. Co-defendant Anchor Bay is also acquitted but is admonished for doing the bare minimum on the DVD package. Court is adjourned.
Give us your feedback!
What's "fair"? Whether positive or negative, our reviews should be unbiased, informative, and critique the material on its own merits.
Scales of Justice
Studio: Anchor Bay
• Preview Trailer
Review content copyright © 2000 Barrie Maxwell; Site design and review layout copyright © 2016 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.