Judge Clark Douglas loves New York, but he's going to propose to Chicago.
Our review of New York, I Love You (Blu-Ray), published February 4th, 2010, is also available.
Every moment…love begins.
So here's how this thing works. A group of directors are each given two days to shoot a short film and one week to edit it. Then another director finds a way to string all of the sequences together in an organic manner. This was the basic idea for the 2006 film Paris, je T'aime, and now it's being repeated for a sort-of sequel, New York, I Love You. As you might expect, the film is a mixed bag of pleasurable little treats and off-key misfires. Let's take a look at them one by one.
• A younger man (Hayden Christensen, Star Wars Episode III: Revenge of the Sith)
follows a younger woman (Rachel Bilson, The O.C.) into a bar, and attempts to
charm her by helpfully "finding" items that he actually stole from
her. He then meets her older boyfriend (Andy Garcia, The Godfather: Part III), who has a
few tricks of his own. Directed by Jiang Wen.
• A Hasidic Jewish woman (Natalie Portman, V for Vendetta) and a Hindu shop owner
(Irrfan Khan) reflect on the challenging complexities of their religions while
simultaneously flirting with each other and conducting a negotiation of sorts.
Directed by Mira Nair.
• A struggling film composer (Orlando Bloom, The Lord of the Rings: The Return of
the King) attempts to figure out why a director dislikes so much of his
score while talking on the phone to his girlfriend (Christina Ricci, Black Snake Moan). Directed by
• A teenager (Anton Yelchin, Star Trek (2009)) takes the
wheelchair-bound daughter (Olivia Thirlby, Juno)
of a local pharmacist (James Caan, The
Godfather) to a prom. Directed by Brett Ratner.
• A man (Bradley Cooper, All About Steve) and a woman (Drea
De Matteo, The Sopranos) have wildly
different feelings about their most recent date as they walk towards a bar to
meet up for the second time. Directed by Allen Hughes.
• A father (Carlos Acosta) and his little girl (Taylor Geare, Four Christmases) enjoy a pleasant day
in the park together. Directed by Natalie Portman.
• A painter (Ugur Yucel, The Bandit) struggles with his
latest work and follows a woman (Shu Qi, The Transporter) who works at a local
grocery store in the hopes of convincing her to model for one of his portraits.
Directed by Fatih Akin.
As anthology films go, New York, I Love You falls short of Jim Jarmusch's consistently brilliant Coffee and Cigarettes, but fares better than say, Four Rooms. Many of the shorts are rather slight, but they're quietly appealing and well-acted for the most part. Though all of these basically qualify as dramatic shorts, the ones that contain a bit of comic flair were the ones I found most appealing. Anton Yelchin's bewildered confusion throughout his segment is very amusing, while Ethan Hawke's profane monologue is a filthy pleasure with a terrific punchline. I'm also very fond of the sweet little sketch involving Cloris Leachman and Eli Wallach. "Pick up your feet," she insists. "You're shuffling. Be careful, or you'll fall and break your other hip." "Well, at least my pain would be the same on both sides," he grumbles. These two old pros nail their roles, making the short of one of the best of the film.
Many of the shorts simply consist of quiet conversations, which vary depending on the skill of the actors involved and the story being provided by the director. For instance, the Allen Hughes segment featuring Drea De Matteo and Bradley Cooper just rambles aimlessly toward a dull payoff, while the pleasant Shunji Iwai segment featuring Orlando Bloom and Christina Ricci quietly works its way to a very charming conclusion. Both are basically just two low-key chats between a man and a woman, but seemingly little things go a long way toward the fate of each short. My single favorite little moment in the film comes during the conversation between Chris Cooper and Robin Wright Penn. They don't know each other. She suggests that strangers ought to have sex now and then. "Now you're just teasing me," Cooper says sheepishly. "I believe I am," she grins. It also has a genuinely wonderful twist ending, less cutesy and more moving than many of the endings these shorts receive.
For the most part, the shorts are very pleasant and accessible, though the segment starring John Hurt, Shia Labeouf, and Julie Christie is a very unusual bit of highbrow art that is simultaneously classically beautiful and incomprehensible. I still don't know precisely what to make of it; particularly Labeouf's odd Russian accent. Also somewhat peculiar is Fatih Akin's segment about the painter and his would-be model, which has some nice little moments but never quite clicks.
The transfer is excellent, offering deep blacks, rich detail and strong shading throughout. The aesthetic of some segments is a little more appealing than others (I think the Allan Hughes segment just looks flat-out ugly, while the two Yvan Attal segments make similar nighttime settings much more involving), but the quality of the disc is solid throughout. Audio is fine, with sound design mostly kept to a minimum and the sentimental music coming through with warmth and clarity. Dialogue is clean and clear most of the time, too. Extras include a handful of additional scenes, interviews with five of the directors and a trailer.
It's a bit too insubstantial to be worth a purchase, but New York, I Love You has enough of value to at least justify a rental. Give it a look.
Give us your feedback!
What's "fair"? Whether positive or negative, our reviews should be unbiased, informative, and critique the material on its own merits.
Scales of Justice
Studio: Vivendi Visual Entertainment
• Deleted Scenes
Review content copyright © 2010 Clark Douglas; Site design and review layout copyright © 2016 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.