Judge David Johnson is fan of these idiot cops, but this compilation disc brings nothing new to the interrogation table.
I really like this show. At times, Reno 911! hits some righteous comic highs and gets me bellowing aloud for all to hear. It's a gag-a-minute COPS take-off, a platter of quick set-ups and skits, helmed by the hapless Reno SheriffÂ's department. Because of its rapid-fire format, some jokes, of course, tank, but the ratio of funny-to-not-funny works in Reno's favor.
The series is an improv-heavy, ensemble comedy, headlined by Deputies Jones (Cedric Yarbrough), Williams (Niecy Nash), Junior (Ben Garant), Garcia (Carlos Alazraqui), Johnson (Wendi McLendon-Covey), Weigel (Kerri Kenney), Kimball (Mary Birdson) and Lieutenant Dangle (Thomas Lennon). Each character has a personality quirk (e.g. Jones sleeps with anything that moves, Weigel is psychotic, Garcia's a racist rage-a-holic), but all are clueless when it comes to policing. The gimmick is actually a fertile joke landscape, and the talent charged with bringing the funny on, for the most part, succeeds.
That being said, the purpose of this disc is lost on me. (Okay, I'm not that naïve, Comedy Central is milking a hit series and trying to make some coin as well as hype up the upcoming theatrical release Reno 911! Miami.) Other than offering someone a sampling of the episodes cheaper than full-season sets, this Most Wanted set serves very little purpose. The seven shows tagged as "very best" to earn entry into the compilation are all good, though not much better than their brethren. To me, they're just seven random shows:
• "Scavenger Hunt"
• "Homeland Security (Parts 1 and 2)"
• "Revered Gigg LeCarp"
• "Officer Smiley"
• "Reading Ron"
• "Rick from Citizen's Patrol"
As I said, good episodes. "Scavenger Hunt," "Reading Ron" and "Officer Smiley" are especially funny and feature some all-time gags (the cat incident in "Reading Ron" is spectacular). The show handles guest stars especially well, as exhibited in the majority of these episodes. The characters are memorable and represent the only semblance of a continuous narrative in the individual episodes.
So, is this set worth picking up? The only audience I can think of that would be interested would be non-committal passersby, hesitant on pulling the trigger for the full seasons sets. For Reno devotees, there isn't anything on this disc that you haven't seen.
The compilation preserves the full frame, 2.0 stereo treatment from the season releases and only two extra accompany: a 14-minute hodgepodge of scenes called "The Deputies Favorite Calls" and the underwhelming live musical performance of "Don't Steal Cable."
Give us your feedback!
What's "fair"? Whether positive or negative, our reviews should be unbiased, informative, and critique the material on its own merits.
Scales of Justice
Studio: Comedy Central
• The Deputies' Favorite Calls
Review content copyright © 2007 David Johnson; Site design and review layout copyright © 2016 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.