DVD Verdict
Home About Deals Blu-ray DVD Reviews Upcoming DVD Releases Contest Podcasts Judges Jury Room Contact  

Case Number 16961

Buy Icons Of Screwball Comedy: Volume One at Amazon

Icons Of Screwball Comedy: Volume One

If You Could Only Cook
1935 // 71 Minutes // Not Rated
Too Many Husbands
1940 // 81 Minutes // Not Rated
My Sister Eileen
1942 // 96 Minutes // Not Rated
She Wouldn't Say Yes
1945 // 86 Minutes // Not Rated
Released by Sony
Reviewed by Appellate Judge James A. Stewart (Retired) // August 5th, 2009

• View Appellate Judge Stewart's Dossier
• E-mail Appellate Judge Stewart
• Printer Friendly Review

Every purchase you make through these Amazon links supports DVD Verdict's reviewing efforts. Thank you!


All Rise...

Appellate Judge James A. Stewart notes that poor economies mean sleeping on the porch, at least for movie leading men.

Editor's Note

Our review of My Sister Eileen, published March 21st, 2005, is also available.

The Charge

"Is that the only bed?"

Opening Statement

In If You Could Only Cook, Jean Arthur's Joan might be pretending she's married to Herbert Marshall's Jim, but she's not even going to share a bedroom with him, let alone a double bed. No, he's sleeping on the porch. Sleeping arrangements are a common thread in Icons of Screwball Comedy: Volume One. In Too Many Husbands, Jean Arthur finds herself an accidental bigamist—and sends both husbands to the guest room. She Wouldn't Say Yes finds Rosalind Russell and Lee Bowman assigned to the same sleeping berth on a train. Even the relatively tame My Sister Eileen finds a male houseguest staying in the kitchen and two sisters spending their first night in a basement apartment without curtains or blinds on the window.

While you might see an occasional screwball comedy made today, the byzantine rules of the Production Code which put an emphasis on sleeping arrangments in film made them a cinematic necessity. The comic deceptions and bizarre situations were a way of injecting romance and titillation into movies while playing by the rules.

The icons on Volume One are actresses Jean Arthur and Rosalind Russell. While the leading ladies are familiar, you're likely to be unfamiliar with the movies from the 1930s and 1940s featured.

Facts of the Case

Icons of Screwball Comedy: Volume One features four movies on two discs, plus a bonus short. Each disc focuses on a female movie star: Jean Arthur on Disc One, Rosalind Russell on Disc Two.

Disc One

• If You Could Only Cook
"Do you, Evelyn Fletcher, take the Buchanan millions to have and to hold, now—"
"And as long as the dough lasts."
Shortly before his wedding to society golddigger Evelyn Fletcher, auto company chief James Buchanan (Herbert Marshall, The Fly) storms out of a business meeting and takes a walk. He meets Joan (Jean Arthur, You Can't Take It With You), who's sitting on a park bench reading the newspaper help wanted ads. Mistaking Buchanan for another unemployment statistic, she suggests they take a job together as cook and butler. They end up working for Rossini, a racketeer who has eyes on Joan himself.

• Too Many Husbands
"You can't tell a woman to meet her dead husband at eight o' clock. You just can't."
Vicki (Jean Arthur) just heard from her father that Bill (Fred MacMurray, Double Indemnity), believed dead, spent a year stranded on a desert island and has returned home. Unfortunately, Vicki is now married to Bill's best friend Henry (Melvyn Douglas, That Uncertain Feeling). Both men have been too busy with other things—Bill's a world traveler and Henry's obsessed with business—to pay attention to Vicki, so now she's got them where she wants them—or so she thinks. Based on a play by W. Somerset Maugham.

• Ain't Love Cuckoo?
This bonus short takes the plot of Too Many Husbands to extremes, with two military couples, everyone believing they've lost their spouse, doing a flip-flop of a remarriage. It's mostly slapstick with Murphy beds and people who can't hold their liquor and the like. It's not a memorable short, but it fits well in a set with Husbands.

Disc Two

• My Sister Eileen
"Look, life passes up and down in front of you like a regular parade. What more could a young person with a typewriter want?"
Venetian blinds is what Ruth (Rosalind Russell, The Front Page) and her sister Eileen (Janet Blair, The Fuller Brush Man) want when they move into a Greenwich Village basement apartment. What they've got is a parade of irregulars, like a football player hiding from his mother-in-law, an amorous newspaperman, an artist landlord who can't get anyone to come to his one-man show, Portuguese merchant marines, and the Three Stooges (in a cameo at the end). An editor urges Ruth to write about all of this. The original source material was stories by Ruth McKenney, by way of a stage play. A better-known remake with Jack Lemmon and Janet Leigh followed.

• She Wouldn't Say Yes
"I have a feeling that meeting under other circumstances, I would have liked you—very much."
Cartoonist Michael Kent (Lee Bowman, Bataan), on his way to military service in Japan, has just run into psychologist Dr. Susan Lane (Rosalind Russell)—literally—at the train station. With a little help from a romantically minded ticket man, they collide again on the train. Everyone wants Michael and Susan to get together—except Susan and a beautiful patient who wants Michael for herself.

The Evidence

While it might not fit your definition of "screwball comedy" because it centers around the strong bond between the two sisters and puts the usual romantic complications and comic deceptions in a supporting role, My Sister Eileen is the high point of the collection. It shows off Rosalind Russell in full sarcastic glory as Ruth comments on her kid sister's various suitors, at the same time serving as Eileen's supporter and protector. Janet Blair is charming as Eileen, the innocent who unwittingly has every man in sight under her spell. The relationship between pessimistic Ruth and optimistic Eileen feels authentic. The goings-on are farcical—at least I'd hope there's never been a riot caused by too many suitors—but feel like exaggeration of reality, not imagination, as Ruth and Eileen complain about subsisting on spaghetti, Ruth's late-ngiht meeting with an editor in the street is cut short by neighbors throwing stuff to shut them up, or a dog chases a cat through the apartment.

Russell, with the help of an excellent sparring partner in Lee Bowman, makes She Wouldn't Say Yes into a great comedy as well. Here, she's a psychologist who casts a spell on the men around her, but doesn't want to take a chance on a relationship herself. Bowman plays a cartoonist whose character—"that little fiend who goes around whistling people to destruction," as Lane puts it—is an imp named Nixie who urges people into impulsive action, and he believes what he draws. Russell keeps Lane's growing feelings for Kent hidden until the last reel, making for a memorable meltdown.

In If You Could Only Cook, Jean Arthur plays a tough cookie with a soft center as Joan. As she talks about sleeping on a park bench, Arthur convinces viewers that she's been through a lot. It makes the initial deception of posing as Jim's wife to get a cook's job more than just a comic contrivance, instead making it a hopeful act in a desperate situation. Her jokes about marrying James Buchanan for his money when she reads about the society nuptials, unaware that the poor slob she's falling for is really Buchanan, seem more like a pep talk to her friend. Even when Joan's letting out a torrent of vitriol as she learns of Jim's deception, her true romantic feelings come across. Herbert Marshall sounds a little too well-bred for the hands-on engineer type of corporate head, but he turns it around as Buchanan quickly gets into the role of the perfect butler. Lionel Stander (Hart to Hart) appears as Flash, Rossini's henchman, who suspects that the new butler is a phony, and there's a good scene with Buchanan's own butler, who gives his boss tips on buttling while some real emotions brew under the surface.

The Great Depression is a running theme of the 1934 comedy, with Joan fearing a night on a park bench as her job search fizzles and sticking it out in a less-than-perfect situation because she knows what's out there. Even the boardroom talk centers on the Depression, as James Buchanan prepares daring plans for the recovery he's sure is on the way, while board members want to move cautiously for an economic siege. The glimpse of the world beyond the movie's farcical bubble adds some depth, and you might see a reflection of today's economic concerns.

I was disappointed with Too Many Husbands, probably because I prefer James Garner and Doris Day in the very similar Move Over, Darling. It could also be that Jean Arthur's Vicki rarely seems to connect with either of her two husbands. She seems more like a tormentor, urging them into slapstick rivalry, than a woman torn between these two men, and in the end, it's a judge—not Vicki, who decides who she should be with. Fred MacMurray is athletic as a slapstick comedian, leaping furniture as he paces a room. Melvyn Douglas' timid workaholic getting up the bravery to fight for his wife usually just comes across as petulant.

The picture and sound quality held up surprisingly well. I didn't notice any of the scratches and flecks you'd expect from movies of this vintage.

Only two trailers are included here, for She Wouldn't Say Yes and My Sister Eileen. I'd watch them after you see the films; the She Wouldn't Say Yes trailer gives away too much of the plot, while My Sister Eileen's trailer doesn't say much of anything.

The Rebuttal Witnesses

Sony showcases the familiar face of Fred MacMurray, who appears in Too Many Husbands, on the cover of Icons of Screwball Comedy: Volume One even though the set focuses on Jean Arthur and Rosalind Russell. Wouldn't Russell, of His Girl Friday fame, have been a better choice?

I reviewed the first two volumes of this series together. There's no reason not to buy this set, but if you can only spring for one, I'd recommend Icons of Screwball Comedy: Volume Two, mainly for Irene Dunne's hilarious Theodora Goes Wild.

Closing Statement

Icons of Screwball Comedy: Volume One has a good batting average for a big box—not literally, since the two discs fit into a slim case—of old movies. Three of the four movies were delights from start to finish and, although I didn't see much chemistry between the leads in Too Many Husbands, it does have some funny moments.

The Verdict

Not guilty, even of unintentional adultery.

Give us your feedback!

Did we give Icons Of Screwball Comedy: Volume One a fair trial? yes / no

Share This Review

Follow DVD Verdict

DVD Reviews Quick Index

• DVD Releases
• Recent DVD Reviews
• Search for a DVD review...


• Classic
• Comedy
• Romantic Comedies

Scales of Justice, If You Could Only Cook

Video: 90
Audio: 90
Extras: 0
Acting: 90
Story: 88
Judgment: 88

Perp Profile, If You Could Only Cook

Studio: Sony
Video Formats:
• Full Frame
Audio Formats:
• Dolby Digital 1.0 Mono (English)
• English (CC)
Running Time: 71 Minutes
Release Year: 1935
MPAA Rating: Not Rated

Distinguishing Marks, If You Could Only Cook

• None

Scales of Justice, Too Many Husbands

Video: 90
Audio: 90
Extras: 70
Acting: 78
Story: 80
Judgment: 78

Perp Profile, Too Many Husbands

Studio: Sony
Video Formats:
• Full Frame
Audio Formats:
• Dolby Digital 1.0 Mono (English)
• English (CC)
Running Time: 81 Minutes
Release Year: 1940
MPAA Rating: Not Rated

Distinguishing Marks, Too Many Husbands

• Short Film

Scales of Justice, My Sister Eileen

Video: 90
Audio: 90
Extras: 40
Acting: 95
Story: 90
Judgment: 93

Perp Profile, My Sister Eileen

Studio: Sony
Video Formats:
• Full Frame
Audio Formats:
• Dolby Digital 1.0 Mono (English)
• English (CC)
Running Time: 96 Minutes
Release Year: 1942
MPAA Rating: Not Rated

Distinguishing Marks, My Sister Eileen

• Trailer

Scales of Justice, She Wouldn't Say Yes

Video: 90
Audio: 90
Extras: 35
Acting: 90
Story: 80
Judgment: 85

Perp Profile, She Wouldn't Say Yes

Studio: Sony
Video Formats:
• Full Frame
Audio Formats:
• Dolby Digital 1.0 Mono (English)
• English (CC)
Running Time: 86 Minutes
Release Year: 1945
MPAA Rating: Not Rated

Distinguishing Marks, She Wouldn't Say Yes

• Trailer

DVD | Blu-ray | Upcoming DVD Releases | About | Staff | Jobs | Contact | Subscribe | Find us on Google+ | Privacy Policy

Review content copyright © 2009 James A. Stewart; Site design and review layout copyright © 2016 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.