Judge David Johnson is an excellent spooner. He should be a professional.
We are all searching for something.
It's nice to be blindsided by a great little surprise once in a while, rather than a steaming dog turd. Thank you Spooner for delivering some unexpected delight.
Facts of the Case
Herman Spooner (Matthew Lillard, Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated) is facing his 30th birthday and, with that, big changes in his life. His parents have mandated he move out of the house by his birthday, despite the fact that Spooner has made it clear that he's not prepared to abandon his man-child status. He's stuck in a dead-end used car salesman job, suffering the endless verbal jabs of his boss, and generally being treated like dirt by all of his peers.
Then one day he meets his dream girl, Rose (Norah Zehetner), and his world changes forever.
I was reminded of (500) Days of Summer watching this, mainly because of the quirky, wry humor and the hapless male pining for his dream girl (granted that applies to nearly every romantic comedy not starring Katherine Heigl, but whatever, I'm trying to make a point here). And while I liked that film, I like Spooner even more; the hapless male is more entertaining and the dream girl isn't a jerk. Plus, this film isn't trying to be any cuter and hipper than it is.
I had zero expectations for Spooner. I had never heard of it, only knew of a couple of the actors, and it showed up on my doorstep as a blind assignment review. Actually, I probably had lower than zero expectations because when I think of Matthew Lillard I flash to the seemingly endless progression of snarking frat boy a-hole characters he's played for the balance of his career.
Did Spooner exceed my diminutive presumptions? Sure, but it's not fair to simply give the movie a pat on its back for going above and beyond my meager standards. Spooner is a genuinely good little movie, a quiet, understated, funny, sweet-natured love story that has one major thing going for it: it features the most likable protagonists I've seen in quite some time.
Lillard is terrific here. Herman Spooner is a sweet guy, naïve, obliviou,s and sort of a doormat. If Lillard dialed up his performance just a few degrees more I would forgive anyone for thinking Spooner was mentally disabled. But Lillard keeps his balance throughout, revealing Spooner to be a lovable lug who is terrified of growing up. This guy isn't a foul-mouthed, pot-addled Appatow creation; he's legitimately scared of leaving the nest, making him instantly root-worthy.
Zehetner's Rose manages to be just as likable. She's extremely cute and nice, never treating Spooner like a jerk. There is malleable affection between the two, and Lillard and Zehetner have a nice chemistry.
In addition to these good feelings, Spooner never feels corny, thanks to pinpoint comedy and a satisfying-but-not-clean-and-buttoned-up ending. Recommended with earnestness.
The DVD: 1.78:1 anamorphic widescreen, 2.0 stereo, and (sadly) no extras.
Looking for a great date movie? Here you go. Just ignore the ridiculous R rating—the "sexual content" refers to a guy making out with a donut.
Give us your feedback!
What's "fair"? Whether positive or negative, our reviews should be unbiased, informative, and critique the material on its own merits.
Scales of Justice
Studio: Maya Entertainment
Review content copyright © 2011 David Johnson; Site design and review layout copyright © 2013 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.