Appellate Judge James A. Stewart has never met a bison.
"I was so nearly born in America…"
British comic actor Stephen Fry tells the story of how his dad rejected a job at Princeton at the start of Stephen Fry in America. He's finally turned up here, though, at the wheel of a London cab. His goal for the six-part series is to travel to every state in the United States. Some, like Maryland and Delaware, he just drives through, but he manages to stop in most states to have conversations, visit interesting places, and crack jokes.
Facts of the Case
Stephen Fry in America contains six episodes on two discs:
• "Deep South"
• "True West"
Stephen Fry's take on America is almost always upbeat, which can occasionally be jarring as he shifts gears and drops a mention of the Kent State tragedy or the Seattle suicide rate into otherwise cheerful proceedings. Mostly, though, his goofiness is surprisingly disarming, opening up conversation in all situations, whether it's an ice-cream development session at Ben & Jerry's, or a walk through a body farm.
The show also knows when to let people speak for themselves: Fry plays a minimal role in the segment at the Alabama pardon and parole hearings, with actual footage from the hearings carrying the segment. That footage of testimony has more impact than anything a narrator could add. The balance of the silly and the serious is handled well.
Fry seems to favor the iconic images of America. You'll notice that he spends more time in the West, a region known for its impact on the American myth. Fry's up on pop culture, even to the point of delivering a Clint Eastwood speech without error at a firing range (he still doesn't sound like Dirty Harry, though).
The picture is sharp and clear, making sites such as Lake Powell or Monument Valley look breathtaking. The music includes some of the ironic travelogue melodies you'd expect but is surprisingly varied.
There are no extras. The sort of details you'd find at the Travel Channel site would have been helpful as a text feature.
The Rebuttal Witnesses
If you're looking for a family travelogue, this isn't it. Most of it is, but there are some naughty bits, particularly a trip to the Mustang Ranch and a discussion of horse breeding in Kentucky that includes the sight of a man with the state outline tattooed on his derriere.
In one segment of Stephen Fry in America, you'll notice that Fry has his arm in a sling. Thus, it appears that he was going back and forth between this travelogue and Last Chance to See, which shows Fry breaking his arm. Stephen Fry in America doesn't do quite as well as Last Chance to See, but it will still provide a fresh look at the country through an (almost) insider's eyes. The stories of Hmong immigrants or the sight of young Lakota students learning their traditional language, to mention a couple of memorable segments, are presented with the right combination of drama and optimism to reassure viewers that America will continue thriving.
Not guilty. Maybe Stephen Fry's dad should have taken that job.
Give us your feedback!
What's "fair"? Whether positive or negative, our reviews should be unbiased, informative, and critique the material on its own merits.
Scales of Justice
Studio: BFS Video
Review content copyright © 2010 James A. Stewart; Site design and review layout copyright © 2016 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.