Judge Dennis Prince is looking to head-slap the chiselers responsible for this disc.
Our reviews of The Three Stooges Collection (published March 20th, 2002), The Three Stooges: Cops And Robbers (published September 26th, 2002), The Three Stooges: G.I. Stooge (published November 14th, 2002), The Three Stooges In Orbit (published December 17th, 2003), The Three Stooges: Stooges On The Run (published October 10th, 2006), and The Three Stooges: Stop! Look! And Laugh! (published April 25th, 2003) are also available.
Wise guys, eh?
The Three Stooges need little introduction and, because of that, their theatrical short subjects and feature-length films are high on Stoogeheads' DVD want lists. Columbia Pictures has been actively issuing shiny discs of the troupe's material for the past five or so years, but with 190 shorts having been made, there's plenty of work to do and no disc can arrive as a wasted effort, in part or in total.
The problem with this particular release, Hapless Half-Wits, is that it consists of a scant four shorts, two of which had been released previously. To that end, this new release cannot be of much joy to fans, who've withstood the unsteady antics of Columbia and their strange habits of head-bonking one of their most popular catalog subjects.
But if this is just those nonsensical nitwits and their lowest-brow humor on display, why do folks get so uptight when a disc like this comes along? Plainly speaking, the impact and importance of the Stooges cannot be so simply waved off. They are, to a man, the perpetual best friends, the brash and base head-butting buddies, and are elemental of the primordial goo that caused prehistoric man to first stand erect, raise his hand, and jab a two-finger eye poke at Ogg standing across from him. Although women don't understand their fascination (very few do, anyway) to men, the Stooges collectively comprise the essence of a third testicle (three stooges, indeed), and, therefore, they are quintessential to the male life experience. So when Columbia continues in its uncalculated sputters and spurts of Stooge material on DVD, it's like a kick in the basket to men worldwide.
Why I oughta…
Specifically, here's what's on this disc and some details about why it's about as welcome as a saw blade dragged over a stubbled cranium:
• Dopey Dicks (1949)
This is a decent short that utilizes the well-tread story thread of the Stooges cowering in the clutches of an evil scientist. The setups work well and the humor is well delivered. The only trouble is this particular short had been previously included in 2001's Merry Mavericks DVD and, therefore, is a no gain for Stoogeheads.
• Beer Barrel Polecats (1945)
This is a remarkably disjointed and illogical adventure, not by original intent but, rather, because this was produced at the time Curly had fallen ill. While the opening sequences of the beer-making mayhem are new, the remainder of the exploits had been egregiously cobbled from So Long, Mr. Chumps and In the Sweet Pie and Pie. You'll be challenged to follow the flow of this one since you're never sure why they guys are sentenced to death and are seeking out the unexplained prisoner 41144.
• Brideless Groom (1947)
This is a perennial favorite among fans yet, because it's one of the public domain titles, it has been released to death already. Again, a no gain for enthusiasts.
• I'll Never Heil Again (1941)
Finally, some fresh meat. This is the first-ever appearance of this Nazi-based caper on DVD and its most welcome. Seemingly, then, the whole point of this disc was for Columbia to release this particular short and pad it with fluff in order to con fans out of some dough. Why those swindlers—I'll murderize 'em.
So, you can see that hapless half-wits are truly at work in the program selection department at old Columbia Studios. This just doesn't make for a compelling collection, and hapless fans who simply must have I'll Never Heil Again in their libraries will sigh heavily as they fork out the skins to buy this overpriced offering. Oh, but what about that Chroma Choice feature, the one that lets you toggle between viewing the shorts in their original black-and-white or now in glorious color? News flash: there's nothing glorious about the Stooges in color; they are of the black-and-white era and belong as such. The colorization process here, while decent, absolutely destroys the mood and era of the Stooges' exploits. For example, the spooky mansion setting where the evil Professor stalks Moe, Larry, and Shemp is absolutely undone by the addition of color, as if someone turned the lights on in the middle of a séance. It's a real deal-breaker and hardly a "feature" to be boasted.
As presented in their original black-and-white format, the detail levels are very much improved over other such releases, and the source prints are reasonably free of distracting elements. Delivered in the standard 1.33:1 full frame aspect ratio, this is how the Stooges are to be properly enjoyed. The audio is presented in Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono and it's quite robust, if not a bit stretched at the high end. Overall, it's a clean presentation.
Despite Columbia's efforts to count each short twice (black-and-white and colorized) to stretch this to a tantalizing 137-minute run time, the fact is you'll only get about 69 minutes of unique material.
Without a doubt, Columbia is guilty of another kick below the belt to Stoogeheads everywhere. The Stooges themselves are not guilty. (I'm a victim of soicumstance!
Give us your feedback!
What's "fair"? Whether positive or negative, our reviews should be unbiased, informative, and critique the material on its own merits.
Scales of Justice
Review content copyright © 2007 Dennis Prince; Site design and review layout copyright © 2015 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.