DVD Verdict
Home About News Blu-ray DVD Reviews Upcoming DVD Releases Contest Podcasts Forums Judges Contact  

Judge Dossier

Chief Counsel Rob Lineberger

Chief Counsel Rob Lineberger • Joined: October 2002
• Retired: December 2009
• 324 full reviews
• 148 small claims

• Read Chief Counsel Lineberger's Blog

 

Rulings

Abigail Leslie Is Back In Town
The Adventures Of Indiana Jones
Ai Yori Aoshi Enishi: Fate (Volume 1)
Ai Yori Aoshi Enishi: Bond (Volume 2)
Ai Yori Aoshi Enishi: Destiny (Volume 3)
The Alamo
Ali: Fear Eats The Soul: Criterion Collection
All Purpose Cultural Cat Girl Nuku Nuku Dash!: The Complete Collection
All Purpose Cultural Cat Girl Nuku Nuku TV: Complete Collection
Android Kikaider: Lonely Soul
Angelic Layer: The Complete Collection
Angel On The Right
Angels With Dirty Faces
Angel Tales: Sweet Transmigration (Volume 1)
The Animal: Uncut And Untamed
Anita: The Shocking Account Of A Young Nymphomaniac
Anna Christie
Appleseed
Atanarjuat (The Fast Runner)
The Avengers '62
The Avengers: The Complete Emma Peel Megaset (Collector's Edition)
Awake: The Best Of Live (Deluxe Version CD/DVD)
Baadasssss Cinema: A Bold Look At '70s Blaxploitation Films
Baba Yaga
Baby Moves
Bad Day At Black Rock
Bad Dreams
Bad Timing: Criterion Collection
Battle Of The Brave
BBC Atlas Of The Natural World: Western Hemisphere And Antarctica
Beerfest: Completely Totally Unrated
Belle Epoque
A Bell From Hell
Bent: Trilogy
The Best Of The Electric Company (Volume 2)
Beverly Hills 90210: The First Season
Beyblade: Hidden Tiger
Big Alligator River
The Big Bad Swim
Bikini Bandits: Briefs, Shorts, And Panties
Billabong Odyssey
Bill Engvall: Here's Your Sign Live
Black Beauty
Black Lagoon: Volume 1
Black Shampoo
Black Snake Moan
Black Venus
Black Widow
Bliss
Blonde Ice
Blood And Black Lace: Unslashed Collector's Edition
Blood Of Heroes
Blood Reign: Curse Of The Yoma
Blood+: Volume Two
The Blue Iguana
The Boondock Saints: Special Edition
Breaking Up
Breasts: A Documentary
Brief Crossing
Broken Wings
Brown Sugar
The Busy Little Engine
Caillou's Family Fun
The Calamari Wrestler
Californication: The First Season
Camera
The Cat's Meow
The Challenge 2.0
Charlie's Angels: The Complete First Season
Charmed: The Complete Fifth Season
Charmed: The Complete Sixth Season
Charmed: The Complete Seventh Season
The Cheetah Girls
Chips: The Complete First Season
Chobits: My Only Person (Volume 6)
Christina
Chrono Crusade: The Complete Collection
City By The Sea
City Hunter
Colt 38 Special Squad
The Conformist
Conquest
The Constant Gardener
Count Basie: Swinging At His Best
The Courtesans Of Bombay
Cowboy Bebop Remix 1
Cowboy Bebop Remix 2
Crazy Love
CSI: Miami: The Complete Fourth Season
CSI: NY: The Second Season
Cult Camp Classics 1: Sci-Fi Thrillers
Curious George: Rocket Ride And Other Adventures
Daddy, Darling
Damaged Care
Dane Cook: Harmful If Swallowed
Danger Man: The Complete First Season
Danger Mouse: The Final Seasons
Dare To Repair: A Do It Herself Guide To Home Improvement
Dawson's Creek: The Complete Fourth Season
The Day Reagan Was Shot
Dead Like Me: The Complete First Season
Deadwood: The Complete First Season
Death Trance
Definitely, Maybe
The Departed: Special Edition
Desert Hearts
The Devil And Daniel Webster: Criterion Collection
The Devil Lady: The Complete Collection
Diggers
Dilbert: The Complete Series
Dinosaurs: The Complete Third And Fourth Seasons
Dora The Explorer: Super Babies
The Doris Day Show: Season Two
Dottie Gets Spanked
The Double Life Of Veronique
Dreammaster: Erotic Invader
Eating Raoul
Eavesdropper
Eden's Bowy Collection
The Emmanuelle Collection
Eugenie
Facing Windows
Fallen Angel
Family Guy: Volume One
Fast Food My Way With Jacques Pepin: Volume 2
Fat Girl: Criterion Collection
Fear Factory: Bite The Hand That Bleeds And Related Archetypal Imagery
Female Prisoner #701: Scorpion: Grudge Song
Femme Fatale
52 Pick-Up
Fighting Spirit: The First Step (Volume 1)
Fighting Spirit: Debut Match (Volume 2)
Fighting Spirit: Test Of Endurance (Volume 3)
The Film Crew: Hollywood After Dark
Illegal (1955)
Final Fantasy: Unlimited: Phase 1
The First Snow Of Winter
The Five Star Stories
Flashdance
Forbidden Hollywood Collection, Volume One
Forbidden Zone: Alien Abduction
Force Of Evil
Forever Knight: The Trilogy, Part 3
Forever Mozart
Forgotten Noir: Portland Expose / They Were So Young (Volume 1)
Fortress Of Amerikkka
42nd Street Pete's Busty Stag Collection: 8mm Madness Part IV
The 40 Year-Old Virgin: Double Your Pleasure Edition
Freeway (1988)
Frida
Full Frame Documentary Shorts (Volume 3)
Full Metal Panic: Mission 01
Full Metal Panic: Mission 02
Full Metal Panic: Mission 03
Full Metal Panic: Mission 04
Full Metal Panic: Mission 05
Full Metal Panic: Mission 06
Full Metal Panic: Mission 07
Galaxy Angel: What's Cooking? (Volume 1)
Galaxy Angel: Stranded Without Dessert (Volume 3)
Geneshaft: Halo (Volume 2)
Geneshaft: Orbit (Volume 3)
Geneshaft: Mobius (Volume 4)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex (Volume 1)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex (Volume 2)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex (Volume 3)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex (Volume 4)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex (Volume 5)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex (Volume 6)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex (Volume 7)
Ghost In The Shell: Stand Alone Complex: Solid State Society
Giovannona, Long-Thigh
Girl Slaves Of Morgana Le Fay
Girls Will Be Girls
God Told Me To
Going Under
Good Bye Lenin!
Graveyard Of Honor
Gravion: Divine Steel (Volume 1)
Gun Crazy
Guys And Dolls: Deluxe Edition
.hack//SIGN Ver. 02: Outcast
.hack//SIGN Ver. 03: Gestalt
.hack//SIGN Ver. 04: Omnipotence
Hamilton Mattress
Happy Lesson: Mama Mia
Havoc: Unrated Version
Heat: Special Edition
The Heiress
Hellsing Ultimate Series: 1
The Heroin Busters
Highlander: The Raven
Highlander: The Series, Season One
Highlander: The Series, Season Two
Highlander: The Series, Season Three
Highlander: The Series, Season Four
Highlander: The Series, Season Five
Highlander: The Series, Season Six
Highlander: The Search For Vengeance
Highlander: Ultimate Collection
Highway To Heaven: Season Three
Hill Street Blues: The Complete First Season
Hoodwinked
Hotel Exotica
The Householder
How To Kill A Judge
The H.P. Lovecraft Collection: Out Of Mind (Volume 3)
The H.P. Lovecraft Collection: Pickman's Model (Volume 4)
Immoral Women
The Inconfessable Orgies Of Emmanuelle
An Inconvenient Truth
Indiscretion Of An American Wife / Terminal Station: Criterion Collection
Inside Out
In The Presence Of Nature
Intimate Strangers
Invincible (Jefery Levy Film)
Isle Of The Dead / Bedlam
I Spy Returns
I Wake Up Screaming
JAG: The Complete Second Season
James Bond Ultimate Edition (Volume 1)
James Bond Ultimate Edition (Volume 4)
Jeff Cesario: You Can Get A Hooker Tomorrow Night
John Carpenter's Vampires (Alternate Opinion)
Jubei Chan The Ninja Girl #1: Secret Of The Lovely Eyepatch
The Jungle Book 2
The Junky's Christmas
K-19: The Widowmaker
Kai Doh Maru
KatieBird *Certifiable Crazy Person
Kekko Kamen
Kiki's Delivery Service
Killer Nun
The Killers: Criterion Collection
Kiss Of Death (1947)
Knight Rider: Season Two
Knight Rider: Season Three
Kolobos
Kurau Phantom Memory: Between Two Worlds
La Dolce Vita
Lady Chatterley's Lover
Lady Libertine
La Femme Nikita: The Complete Fifth Season
La Jetee / Sans Soleil (Criterion Collection)
Lamerica
La Petite Lili
The Last American Virgin
L'Atalante
Laura's Toys
Le6ion Of The Dead
Leaving Metropolis
Legong: Dance Of The Virgins
Lemon Sky
Le Samourai: Criterion Collection
Liberated Zone
Lifespan
Like Mike
The Little Colonel
A Little Snow Fairy Sugar: Sweet Mischief
The Lives Of Others
Lois And Clark: The New Adventures Of Superman: The Complete Fourth Season
The Long, Hot Summer
Lords Of Dogtown: Unrated Extended Cut
Lost City Of The Jungle
Love Circles
Love Me If You Dare
L/R (Licensed By Royalty): Targets (Volume 2)
Lucia, Lucia (La Hija Del Canibal)
Lupin III: The Secret Of Mamo
Lupin The Third: Love Heist
Lupin The Third: The World's Most Wanted
Lust For Frankenstein / Tender Flesh
Magnum P.I.: The Complete First Season
Magnum P.I.: The Complete Second Season
Mahoromatic - Automatic Maiden - Something More Beautiful: All Good Things... (Volume 3)
Make Way For Ducklings... And More Robert Mccloskey Stories
Malibu Eyes
The Mambo Kings
Man Bites Dog: Criterion Collection
Mansion Of The Living Dead
Martha's Baking Favorites
Masked Rider: The First
Master Keaton: Excavation I
The Matrix Reloaded
Max And Ruby's Halloween
Max And Ruby: Springtime For Max And Ruby
McLeod's Daughters: The Complete First Season
McLeod's Daughters: The Complete Second Season
Mile High: Season 2 - Part 1
Misty Mundae Euro Vixen Collection
Moonlighting Wives
Moral Orel: Volume 1, The Unholy Edition
The Most Beautiful Wife
Mostly Martha
Mr. Deeds
Mulan: Special Edition
Murder, My Sweet
My New Gun
My Summer Of Love
Naked World
Nature Baby
Neon Genesis Evangelion: Platinum Collection (Volume 1)
Neon Genesis Evangelion: Platinum Collection (Volume 2)
Neon Genesis Evangelion: Platinum Collection (Volume 3)
Neon Genesis Evangelion: Platinum Collection (Volume 4)
Neon Genesis Evangelion: Platinum Collection (Volume 5)
Neon Genesis Evangelion: Platinum Collection (Volume 6)
Neon Genesis Evangelion: Platinum Collection (Volume 7)
Nero Wolfe: The Complete First Season
The Net 2.0
New Dominion Tank Police
NFL Films: Colts: The Complete History
Nice Guys Sleep Alone
Nico And Dani
Night And The City: Criterion Collection
Nine Queens
99 Women
Ninja Resurrection
Noisy Nora... And More Stories About Mischief
No Vacancy (1999)
Nunsensations! The Nunsense Vegas Revue
The O.C.: The Complete Third Season
Once Upon A Time (1987)
Once Upon A Time In America: Special Edition
Orguss 02
Original Dirty Pair: OVA Collection Box
The Original Nancy Drew Movie Mystery Collection
Outrage (1998)
Overnight Delivery
Party Animalz
A Perfect Circle: aMOTION (with CD)
Petty Crimes
Pigalle
Pipe Dream
Plastic Little: The Adventures Of Captain Tita
Plymptoons: The Complete Early Works Of Bill Plympton
Police Woman: First Season
The Pornographer
The Powerpuff Girls Movie
Private Collections
Prizzi's Honor
The Public Enemy
Pump Up The Volume
Punch
Puni Puni Poemy
Pursued (1947)
Q: The Winged Serpent (Blue Underground Edition)
The Radley Metzger Collection (Volume 1)
The Radley Metzger Collection (Volume 3)
RayEarth
Red Garters
Revolver (1973)
Rhythm Of The Dance
Robin Cook's Invasion
Robin Cook's Terminal
The Rockford Files: Season Two
Rodentz
Roughnecks: Starship Troopers Chronicles: The Zephyr Campaign
Rune Soldier: The Complete Collection
Sacred Flesh
Sailor Moon R: The Movie: The Promise Of The Rose
Sailor Moon S: Heart Collection I (Signature Series)
Sailor Moon S: The Movie: Hearts In Ice
Sailor Moon: Uncut Season 1
Saint Seiya: Collection 1
Sakura Wars: The Movie
Samurai X: OVA Collection
Sarah Vaughan And Other Jazz Divas
Saturday Night Fever
Saturday Night Live: The Best Of Gilda Radner
S.A.V.E. Level 1
Saving Grace: Season One
Scarface (1983) Platinum Edition
Scenes Of The Crime
Scrapbook
s-CRY-ed: The Alter Hunt (Volume 2)
seaQuest DSV: Season One
Second Best
Second Skin (2000)
Secret Agent (AKA Danger Man): The Complete Collection
Secrets Of A Call Girl
Secret Things
The Sensuous Nurse
Sex Is Comedy
Sexual Dependency
Shadows, Lies, And Private Eyes: The Film Noir Collection
Shakespeare Wallah
The Shape Of Life
Shattered Image (1999)
The Shield: The Complete First Season
Silk Stalkings: The Complete First Season
Sitcom
Slayers Gorgeous
Slayground
Slingshot
Solo Con Tu Pareja: Criterion Collection
Songcatcher
Species
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, Season Two
Star Trek: The Original Series: Season Three
The Star Wars Trilogy
Star Wars Episode II: Attack Of The Clones
The Stationmaster's Wife
Staying Alive
Stellar Body: Bellydance With Fire
Stormy Weather
A Strange Affair
A Streetcar Named Desire: Two-Disc Special Edition
Strega Nona... And More Caldecott Award-Winning Folk Tales
Suburban Secrets
Superior Defender Gundam Force: The Hero Arrives (Volume 1)
Superior Defender Gundam Force: New Allies (Volume 2)
Sweet Bird Of Youth
Taylor Wane's Erotic Games
Teletubbies: Time To Play
Tenchi Muyo! OVA Volume 1: Signature Series
Tenchi Universe: Volume 1: On Earth (Signature Series)
Tenjho Tenge: Round One
Tenjho Tenge: Round Three
Tenjho Tenge: Round Two
That '70s Show: Season Four
That '70s Show: Season Five
That Tender Touch
The Thin Blue Lie
Thirteen
Those Who Hunt Elves: The Complete Collection
Tokko: Volume 1
Tokko: Volume 2
Tons Of Trouble
Toot And Puddle: I'll Be Home For Christmas
To The Manor Born
Track Of The Cat: Special Collector's Editon
Treasure Planet Read Along
Trois 2: Pandora's Box
Tuck Everlasting
The Two Of Us (Criterion Collection)
2005 Draft Preview
2069: A Sex Odyssey / Run, Virgin, Run
Ubalda, All Naked And Warm
UFO Ultramaiden Valkyrie: Bedlam, Bathhouse and Beyond (Volume 1)
Ultimate X: The Movie
Under The Sun
Underworld Beauty (Ankokugai No Bijo)
Up And Down
Urban Cowboy
Uschi Digard: The Buxom Bombshell Collection
Vacuuming Completely Nude In Paradise
The Valerio Zurlini Box Set: The Early Masterpieces
The Val Lewton Horror Collection
Vermillion Pleasure Night: Creme De La Creme (Volume 3)
Virus: Virus Buster Serge (Volume 3)
Voices Of A Distant Star
Walking With Monsters
The Waltons: The Complete Second Season
The Waltons: The Complete Fourth Season
The Weird Al Show: The Complete Series
Wes Craven Presents: Don't Look Down
Wet Asphalt
What Killed The Mega Beasts?
Where The Sidewalk Ends
Who's That Girl?
The Wild Thornberries Movie
Wings Of Desire
The Witches Of Breastwick
The Witch's Mirror
A Woman Possessed
Women's Prison
Writer Of O
Xena: Warrior Princess, Season One
Xena: Warrior Princess, Season Two
Xena: Warrior Princess, Season Three
You Only Live Twice
Your Vice Is A Locked Room And Only I Have The Key
Yukikaze: Danger Zone (Volume 1)
Zaion: I Wish You Were Here: Epidemic (Volume 1)
Zero Focus
009-1 (Volume 1)

DVD Verdict Quick Index

• Blu-ray Release Dates 2012
• DVD Release Dates 2012
• DVD Reviews 2012
• Search for a DVD review...


Average Scales of Justice

Video: 82
Audio: 81
Extras: 64
Acting: 81
Story: 74
Judgment: 78

Scale Modifiers

Video: +4
Audio: +5
Extras: -5
Acting: +3
Story: +5
Judgment: +1

The Scale Modifiers are the difference between the Judge's average scores and the average scores for the site as a whole. You can add/subtract this value from the score he/she gives in a review to see how their scoring differs from the site as a whole. The adjusted score should not reflect any bias on the part of the judge.






DVD | Blu-ray | Upcoming DVD Releases | About | Staff | Jobs | Contact | Subscribe | Find us on Google+ | Privacy Policy

Copyright © 2014 Verdict Partners LLC. All rights reserved.